Northborough Government News

Unofficial News from Northborough's Government Meetings

Select Board ·

Fire chief makes case for eight grant-funded firefighters as budget summit turns tense

Select Board, November 9, 2026

Meeting summary · Northborough. Written from the meeting's automatically-generated transcripts; names come from voice recognition and may be incomplete.

Northborough's new fire chief spent nearly an hour on a joint budget night arguing that eight firefighter jobs, paid for by a federal SAFER grant that runs out in March 2028, are the difference between a safe department and one where a single captain covers the whole town. Keeping all eight would cost about $862,000 a year starting in FY29. The Select Board, Appropriations Committee and Financial Planning Committee made no decisions. They face a projected $1.6 million operating gap, or $1.8 million counting the firefighters, and $9.8 million in capital requests against about $3 million available. The night's sharpest clashes came when Mike Sciacca pressed for transaction-level spending data and called town spending "out of control," and several members pushed back.

Fire chief pleads to keep eight SAFER-funded firefighters

Watch: 0:41:10–1:38:51

Members of the fire department filled the room, so the board moved the SAFER discussion ahead of the rest of the budget talk. Keith Darling said the federal grant, about $2.8 million over three years, pays the salaries and benefits of eight firefighters. It raised staffing from five to seven per shift. The money runs out at the end of March in FY28. Covering the eight through July 1 would take about $200,000, which he suggested could come from free cash or the ambulance revolving fund. Keeping all eight in FY29 would cost about $862,000, which he put at roughly $129 on the average household's tax bill if the town had to use an override. (0:42:43) (1:09:24)

He described what short staffing looks like on the ground. Nobody is left to run incident command, and crews may enter burning buildings with no rescue team outside. With five on duty, two medical calls can leave a lone captain covering town. "It makes my skin crawl thinking about one captain being back here alone," he said. (0:54:19) He walked through photos of a three-alarm hoarding-house fire he commanded in Franklin, saying, "It took 50 firefighters for that house. We're asking you for seven." (0:58:48) He also described a fatal June crash on Route 290 where a two-person engine worked the scene alone for more than eight minutes. (1:03:26)

The uncertainty is already costing people, he said. Eight firefighters have left for other departments, and that number "just went to nine this week." The latest to leave cited job security. (0:55:04) Mutual-aid ambulance transports fell from 62 in 2024 to 52 in 2025 and 18 this year as the new hires finished training. (1:28:20) He listed ways to offset the cost: raising ambulance rates to the median ($118,000 to $167,000 a year), a Medicaid reimbursement program worth about $51,000 a year, and a possible federal Medicaid enhancement worth $176,000 to $254,000 that is still being researched. (1:09:24) (1:12:16)

Members thanked him warmly. Susan Sartori said her daughter, an emergency room doctor, calls firefighters "the unsung heroes." (1:27:30) George Brenckle asked why ambulance rates should stop at the median. Keith Darling urged caution because insurers push back on providers who charge too much. (1:16:46) Mike Sciacca said the $862,000 was about what new Town Hall carpeting would cost and that he'd "probably rather have firefighters than a carpet." That drew a rebuke from Mike Tietjen: "there's no reason to be combative." (1:15:28) (1:16:02)

Jason Little added that laying off the eight would bring an unbudgeted one-time unemployment cost, possibly around $30,000. (1:36:26) Keith Darling told Jonathan Rea that overtime is hard to predict but that seven per shift around the clock is sustainable once vacancies are filled. No decision was made, and Jonathan Rea said the conversation will be picked up again.

  • “it's more than a spreadsheet. It's more than numbers. It's more than industry standards. It's people's safety.” — Keith Darling (1:04:56)
  • “you got a job on March FY28. You're going to solve a lot of our problems right there.” — Keith Darling (1:38:08)
  • “it's spending money frivolously when we have people's jobs on the line.” — Mike Sciacca (1:16:14)

Clash over line-item spending data and 'status quo' budgeting

Watch: 0:21:21–2:00:51

The first flashpoint came early. Mike Sciacca said the boards "need to stop being reactive" and need visibility into every expenditure "at a transactional level," "not because we think that there's something nefarious going on." He offered ideas: fleet-management tracking, hiring an in-house electrician or plumber instead of paying contractors, buying an existing commercial building rather than spending $4.5 million on a Town Hall HVAC system, and turning Zeh School into a new Town Hall. "Our spending is out of control," he said. (0:21:21) (0:34:21)

Mike Tietjen answered that "starting from scratch" would mostly mean cutting teachers, public safety and the DPW. He said trimming small departments would not change tax bills much. (0:26:15) Scott Rogers said many of the questions had been "asked, explained, answered." He noted that "very vocal individuals" were taking time while firefighters waited to hear whether "they're going to have a job or they're not." (0:35:03) (0:37:05) Mike Sciacca replied that "asked but answered is not acceptable." (0:39:48) Jonathan Rea said nothing raised had been inappropriate and that some of it was new to him. He moved the fire discussion forward but promised to come back to the topic.

When the topic returned, it grew heated over a motion seeking transaction-level data. Ken Picard said the committee had already voted it down and he would bring it back if asked. (1:51:12) Jason Little said outside auditors already review the books, that "not everything that goes through our books is public," and that reviewing thousands of lines would add work. (1:51:51) Leslie Rutan asked why it was being rehashed. She said it "sounds like somebody who isn't getting their way." Later she told him, "You've interrupted everybody." (1:54:02) (1:55:20) He said members had asked for the boards to be made aware before a revote, and asked, "why would you not want that?" (1:55:40)

Terry Halloran spoke even though his committee had not been called to order. "No taxpayer has any business going through every freaking invoice," he said. He added that if the town were run that way, "I want nothing to do with it. I've had enough." (1:56:22) Jonathan Rea closed the topic, saying any next step belongs with the Financial Planning Committee. Before moving on, Mike Sciacca formally asked the board to have Stephanie Bacon pursue a fleet-management system. (2:00:10)

  • “every taxpayer in this town should have a right to see exactly where their money is being spent.” — Mike Sciacca (1:55:40)
  • “We pay these people good money to be good stewards for us” — Terry Halloran (1:56:22)
  • “let's just all speak to each other with respect” — Jonathan Rea (1:39:01)

$1.6M gap, $9.8M in capital wishes and talk of a future override

Watch: 0:07:39–2:57:06

Stephanie Bacon framed the numbers. The projected FY2028 operating gap is $1.6 million without the SAFER positions and $1.8 million with them. Capital requests total $9.8 million against about $3 million available. Union health-insurance concessions could cut the projected increase to about $600,000. (0:09:40) (0:11:16) Jason Little said free cash was certified that afternoon at $4.6 million. His model assumes 3% increases for town departments, 5% for regional school assessments, 10% for retirement and 12% for health insurance, with the schools as "the big question." (0:12:20)

Scott Rogers said the gap is about where it was last year and the town will likely avoid an override this year. He wants a strategy ready: a multi-year override framed around the whole budget, not one department, so residents aren't "fighting with each other." (2:09:47) (2:11:38) He warned about debt. A $70 million, 30-year bond at 5.15% would cost about $5.9 million a year, with Melican Middle School's roof and windows another $9 million: "Going to pay for that in free cash or a bunch of car washes and cookie sales." (2:05:12) (2:06:19)

Mike Sciacca said last year's balancing relied on one-time "tricks." Scott Rogers objected: "These were not tricks. It was not a show." (2:15:45) George Brenckle split the difference. Skipping the OPEB contribution only postponed the bill, he said, so "Mike's not totally wrong." He argued that town costs are rising faster than residents' incomes. He suggested giving departments hard spending targets. (2:17:32) (2:32:00) Stephanie Bacon said departments already get targets, which were cut to 2.9% last year. (2:22:04)

Several ideas came up. Ken Picard proposed a free scientific resident survey through Clark University. He called using free cash to subsidize operations "a mistake." (2:32:52) (2:53:18) Susan Sartori urged care in how members speak: "Words matter." (2:38:04) A proposed stormwater fee drew support from Mike Tietjen, who said it would shift costs to commercial lots with more paved surface. Jonathan Rea called it a "pocket game," and Mike Sciacca called it "a shell game." (2:47:27) (2:48:45) Next steps: a free cash plan, a December 14 joint meeting with the schools, and possibly another session in January.

  • “we can't keep just going back and saying to the taxpayer, you know, well, you've got to eat it.” — George Brenckle (2:21:27)
  • “I don't want to see the battle between departments or contingencies or constituencies” — Scott Rogers (2:11:38)
  • “You don't want $5 million worth of requests on there because then it's going to be infighting” — Ken Picard (2:02:10)

Other business

Opening and public comment

Watch: 0:00:20–0:03:14

Jonathan Rea opened the meeting at 6:31 p.m. Jacob Jones said residents are told at town meeting to raise line-item questions at committee meetings. He said a request for detailed expenditure data at the committee level appeared not to have been granted, and he urged the boards to share it in the name of transparency. (0:01:19)

New manager for La Miette La Mai liquor license

Watch: 0:03:25–0:06:12

Angie Sowden said the current manager is retiring and that the paperwork and background check were complete. Wachira Sittikong said he has worked at the 278 Main Street restaurant since he was 11. (0:04:28)

  • Motion: Approve change of manager for the all-alcohol restaurant license held by Yoong Tong Family Corp d/b/a La Miette La Mai Thai Bistro, subject to ABCC approval — Outcome unclear in captions; the chair congratulated the applicant (0:05:43)

Tax classification ahead of Nov. 23 hearing

Watch: 3:05:20–3:26:50

Jason Little introduced Patty Mespelli, who was on her first day in the job. He explained the small commercial exemption: 25 parcels worth $12 million qualify. A 10% exemption would shift about two cents onto the rest of the commercial-industrial rate. (3:11:25) Most eligible parcels are downtown. (3:13:55)

Board members asked for comparisons with neighboring and similar towns and for shift scenarios of 10%, 15% and 25%. Jonathan Rea cited a Bartlett Street industrial property that sold for $36 million after an earlier $19 million sale while being assessed at $6 million: "So this is about fairness." (3:21:18) Mike Tietjen cautioned that towns with split rates may have to keep widening them. Little public input has come in so far. (3:17:35) (3:24:15)

Legislative priorities for state delegation

Watch: 3:26:50–3:48:14

Members put housing mandates and drones at the top of the list. They also want an MSBA-style funding authority for municipal buildings, state help to sustain grant-funded public safety jobs, and action on the closed Whitney Street Bridge. MassDOT has assigned the bridge design and set a scoping meeting for December 9. (3:28:22) (3:37:42) (3:41:31) Jonathan Rea opposed speed cameras on state roads: "This has not gone well." (3:44:37)

  • Motion: Authorize Stephanie Bacon to finalize legislative priorities incorporating board feedback for the November 23 meeting with the state delegation — Passed (roll call) (3:47:27)

Half-day holiday closures

Watch: 3:50:12–3:51:30

Town offices will close at noon on November 25, December 24 and December 31.

  • Motion: Approve 2026 holiday schedule with noon closures the day before Thanksgiving, Christmas Eve and New Year's Eve — Passed (roll call) (3:50:56)

Meeting minutes

Watch: 3:51:30–3:54:12

Julianne Hirsh asked that the October 5 minutes state what a $30,000 state earmark will fund.

  • Motion: Approve October 5, 2026 open session minutes as amended — Passed 4-0-1, one abstention (3:53:24)
  • Motion: Approve October 19, 2026 open session minutes as presented — Passed 4-0-1, one abstention (3:53:49)

Peasley School project update

Watch: 3:54:12–4:20:44

Mike Tietjen said the building committee presented to the Community Preservation Committee about using CPA money for fields, courts and playgrounds. No application has been filed yet. (3:54:21) The committee chose the construction-manager-at-risk delivery method, estimated at about 2% of a roughly $95 million building cost. Supporters said it should mean fewer change orders and faster pricing. (3:58:40) (4:04:41)

The design goes to the MSBA on December 11. Preschool space was cut from five classrooms to four. K-8 enrollment is projected to stay roughly steady. (4:15:13) Julianne Hirsh suggested public tours of the school. The committee may present at the December 14 meeting.

Amazon drone delivery bylaw

Watch: 4:20:44–4:26:12

Stephanie Bacon reported that Amazon withdrew its Westborough application on October 30. Northborough zoning prohibits uses it does not list, but the building inspector advised a legal review because of FAA rules. (4:20:53)

  • Motion: Refer commercial drone delivery facilities to the Planning Board for possible zoning amendments for the 2027 annual town meeting — Passed (roll call partially captured) (4:24:52)
  • Motion: Authorize Stephanie Bacon to work with town counsel on the town's authority to regulate drone delivery, including a general bylaw, and report back — Passed (roll call partially captured) (4:25:28)

Reports, future agenda and executive session

Watch: 4:26:12–4:31:58

Leslie Rutan asked Stephanie Bacon to survey the remaining members of an unnamed committee that has had two resignations. Members also discussed a recent downtown power outage. The voting-location question is due in December. The board then went into executive session and did not return to open session.

  • Motion: Enter executive session on 4 West Main Street, a public records fee appeal and review of executive session minutes — Passed by roll call (4:31:58)

Who spoke

  • Keith Darling, Fire Chief — 36 min, 53 sec, 18% of speaking time, 171 turns
  • Jonathan Rea, Select Board Chair — 30 min, 19 sec, 14% of speaking time, 234 turns
  • Mike Tietjen, Select Board Vice Chair — 26 min, 40 sec, 13% of speaking time, 168 turns
  • Jason Little, Finance Director — 22 min, 47 sec, 11% of speaking time, 114 turns
  • Mike Sciacca, a Financial Planning Committee member — 18 min, 3 sec, 9% of speaking time, 91 turns
  • Stephanie Bacon, Town Administrator — 17 min, 7 sec, 8% of speaking time, 139 turns
  • Scott Rogers, an Appropriations Committee member — 9 min, 51 sec, 5% of speaking time, 68 turns
  • Jeff Ostiguy, Select Board Member — 8 min, 58 sec, 4% of speaking time, 65 turns
  • Susan Sartori, a Financial Planning Committee member — 6 min, 58 sec, 3% of speaking time, 32 turns
  • Leslie Rutan, Select Board Member — 6 min, 12 sec, 3% of speaking time, 65 turns
  • Julianne Hirsh, Select Board Member — 6 min, 6 sec, 3% of speaking time, 67 turns
  • George Brenckle, an Appropriations Committee member — 5 min, 48 sec, 3% of speaking time, 50 turns
  • Ken Picard, the Financial Planning Committee chair — 5 min, 3 sec, 2% of speaking time, 31 turns
  • Terry Halloran, a committee member and former CFO — 2 min, 42 sec, 1% of speaking time, 13 turns
  • Wachira Sittikong, La Miette La Mai — 2 min, 11 sec, 1% of speaking time, 37 turns
  • Angie Sowden, Executive Assistant — 1 min, 41 sec, 1% of speaking time, 17 turns
  • Jacob Jones, a Green Street resident — 1 min, 35 sec, 1% of speaking time, 12 turns
  • Patty Mespelli, Principal Assessor — 36 sec, 0% of speaking time, 3 turns

Possible Open Meeting Law issues

Any Open Meeting Law issues found for this meeting will be posted after the 30-day complaint period ends on December 9, 2026.

See the Open Meeting Law page on Mass.gov for information on the Open Meeting Law.

Summary last updated Nov 14, 2026 at 12:39 PM.