Peaslee School Building Committee Design Subcommittee ·
Peaslee designers weigh flat roofs and a center entrance as $1,000-a-foot cost looms
Peaslee School Building Committee Design Subcommittee, November 2, 2026
Meeting summary · Northborough. Written from the meeting's automatically-generated transcripts; names come from voice recognition and may be incomplete. Names in italics are likely but not yet confirmed.
With the new Peaslee School estimated at about $1,000 a square foot and only $700 of that eligible for state reimbursement, the design subcommittee spent Monday morning looking for savings. Jake asked whether the planned pitched metal roofs should give way to cheaper flat roofs, and the architects agreed to price flat roofs as an alternate. Members also liked a reworked floor plan that moves the main entrance to the center of the building, and they pressed the design team on how much soil will have to be trucked in and out during two construction phases. No final decisions were made. A follow-up meeting is set for 10 a.m. on Friday, Nov. 13, ahead of the full building committee's Nov. 17 meeting.
Pitched or flat roofs: hunting for savings on a $1,000-a-foot school
Watch: 1:13:17–1:25:13
Near the end of the meeting Jake raised the question of the building's roofs. The plans have shown pitched standing-seam metal roofs, chosen partly to avoid future roof replacements. But he said a sloped roof needs "a lot more structural steel" than flat trusses, on top of the premium for metal over rubber roofing (1:18:31). "I don't want to do it, but it seems to me like the budget might necessitate it," he said (1:14:13).
Ken agreed that pitched roofs "are going to be you know, extremely expensive" and suggested pricing an alternate, such as cutting the pitched roofs by half. He also noted that the public often likes pitched roofs (1:14:40). Mary Coakley asked whether a shallow pitch could "fool the eye." Jennifer said the team would keep pitched roofs on key, prominent volumes and go flat elsewhere, "so that we're spending the money where it's most appreciated" (1:21:49).
Greg Martineau left the roof choice to the subcommittee and said he was "not opposed." He then spelled out the stakes: the cost is "around $1,000 right now" per square foot, "reimbursed at 700." He said the team has to cut costs without hurting the classrooms "because we have to get this passed" (1:22:23).
Tristan backed pricing a flat roof as an alternate, perhaps over the cafeteria. He asked that the comparison include a lifecycle view: one standing-seam roof might last 50 years, while a flat roof might need replacing two or three times. A flat roof could also hold more solar panels (1:23:01). The architects agreed to break out the premium for the gabled roofs and do an alternate massing study.
Kevin Wyrsch asked about solar. Ken said the cost of panels is not in the current budget, but the building will have the code-required provisions for adding them later. Tristan repeated a request for estimates of system size and cost. He said electricity bought on its own is "an expensive fuel source" and that the district has been adding panels to its schools (1:17:16). Jake also worried that the interior classroom commons could end up as spaces that are only lit artificially. The architects said they will focus on bringing in natural light through vertical openings rather than skylights (1:20:35).
- “we're talking about how do we bring the the cost down on this building?” — Jake (1:14:13)
- “pragmatically, what happens inside the building is what the key aspect of of the work is.” — Greg Martineau (1:19:27)
- “if people feel like we haven't done that work, then the likelihood of it passing is less” — Greg Martineau (1:22:23)
Site grading: how much soil comes in, how much goes out
Watch: 0:02:24–0:32:26
Natalie Brown and Bill Brown presented the grading plan. It sets the new building's first floor at elevation 294, a foot below the existing school, and grades the site so no retaining walls are needed. The plan keeps 2 percent slopes for accessible routes and a 1.25 percent slope on the competition field. A first-pass analysis suggests phase one, the new building, may need fill brought in. Phase two, demolishing the old school, may produce extra soil that has to be hauled off. Bill Brown said a real cut-and-fill analysis is still needed, along with geotechnical questions such as whether the ground must be "preloaded" with 4 to 6 feet of fill so it can settle (1:13:30).
Bill Brown also warned that sinking the building lower would mean more fill, the loss of more trees and walls along the west side. He said the steep north slope means a proposed access drive would require removing all trees within its path (0:10:13).
Tristan pushed for balancing the soil within each phase. "Hauling stuff in and then hauling stuff out just for phasing like I've done that before and it's it's it's expensive," he said (0:14:18). Jake wanted the next estimate to include "adequate allowances for the possibility of ledge" so that "we're bringing forward the worst case to the taxpayers" (0:19:52). He also said the earlier fill estimates looked low.
Jake proposed a different approach: use the natural slope for a "walk-out" design that is one story on the west and south sides and two stories on the north and east, instead of "terraforming the entire site" (0:26:35). Ken said that would get complex, possibly requiring extra elevators and ramps, and that elementary schools are kept "as flat as possible." He offered instead to look at setting the athletic fields slightly higher than the building if site costs come in high. When Greg Martineau asked about state reimbursement for site work, an owner's project manager representative said it is now about 10 percent, up from 8 (0:29:46).
Jake said field grading should be "the least important thing" and that the town does not need a "Little League World Series type field." He added that the current field is heavily used, for games like kickball. Members also pressed on phasing. Ken said the permanent roads on the far left and far right must be built in phase one, "or the students would never be able to access the back." Temporary bus drop-off and play areas will be worked out in later phasing plans (0:22:50).
- “use the existing terrain as a tool rather rather than terraforming the entire site” — Jake (0:26:35)
- “no, we're not going to put 9 feet of structural fill.” — Ken (0:16:41)
- “The bus drop-off is going to be the biggest thorn in figuring that out” — Ken (0:23:20)
A center entrance gains favor; design must be set by mid-November
Watch: 0:51:28–1:13:13
Jennifer presented a "what if" layout that moves the main entrance to the middle of the building. Students would turn right toward the classrooms, and visitors would turn left toward the cafeteria, gym and offices, with a possible separate entrance for community use. She noted trade-offs in walking distance and in how visible the entrance is as people approach (0:52:58).
Tristan said the layout shortens the walk from the parent drop-off, which matters "if it's a rainy day." It also makes it easier to close off parts of the building after hours, though the cafeteria ends up "a little bit out of the way" (0:53:50). He later said, "I kind of like this center entrance concept because it seems it seems a little more simple" (1:07:10). Greg Martineau said he preferred it because it "reduces travel time" and separates the classroom wings from operations. Mary Coakley also liked it, saying the view through to the courtyard would make the building "feel very modern" (1:08:08).
Kevin Wyrsch asked why the entrance "always being pushed back into the building" and whether it could be pulled forward so people see it on approach (0:57:12). An owner's project manager representative suggested moving the physical and occupational therapy rooms back by the gym to make room. School officials also discussed where to put the nurse. Greg Martineau favored an exterior door from the nurse's office so a sick student would not have to travel through the school.
Ken said the options use the same pieces and should not swing the cost much. The floor plan has to be settled by mid-November so it can be documented for the Massachusetts School Building Authority. The submission goes "into the binder on December 11th." Members agreed to a follow-up subcommittee meeting at 10 a.m. Friday, Nov. 13, before the full Peaslee Building Committee meets on Nov. 17 (1:12:35).
- “I think the changes that you're playing with are actually um heading in the right direction.” — Greg Martineau (1:08:46)
- “Is there a way to pull the entrance more forward?” — Kevin Wyrsch (0:57:12)
Other business
Call to order and minutes
Watch: 0:00:49–0:02:24
Kevin Wyrsch called the meeting to order at 10:32 a.m. with all three members present. The Oct. 15 minutes were approved.
- Motion: Approve the minutes of the October 15, 2026 meeting — Passed 3-0 (0:01:58)
Floor plan updates: gym-cafeteria flip, community access and preschool rooms
Watch: 0:33:11–0:51:28
Jennifer walked through the revisions. The gym and cafeteria have swapped places, the entry has moved south, the outline has been simplified, and expanded notches create outdoor learning space. The classroom pods have also been reorganized.
Kevin Wyrsch asked how the gym and cafeteria could be opened to the community on nights and weekends without people wandering the building. The plan uses double doors as placeholders, and Ken suggested enclosing the stair to the second floor (0:42:41).
Greg Martineau asked to reduce the preschool classrooms from five to four, because preschool rooms must be about 1,200 square feet. The smaller room would become occupational therapy, and adaptive PE would share space with physical therapy (0:43:43). The school officials explained that "bubble" classrooms let an extra section of a grade fit in the floor plan, though some classes would need to switch rooms from year to year.
Public comment and adjournment
Watch: 1:25:13
No members of the public spoke, and the meeting adjourned.
- Motion: Adjourn — Passed (1:25:13)
Who spoke
- Jennifer (likely), a Flansburgh architect — 13 min, 22 sec, 21% of speaking time, 84 turns
- Jake (likely), a design subcommittee member — 8 min, 57 sec, 14% of speaking time, 86 turns
- Tristan (likely), a design subcommittee member — 8 min, 18 sec, 13% of speaking time, 43 turns
- Ken (likely), a Flansburgh architect — 7 min, 54 sec, 13% of speaking time, 74 turns
- Bill Brown (likely), a Studio Brown landscape architect — 6 min, 6 sec, 10% of speaking time, 14 turns
- Natalie Brown (likely), a Studio Brown landscape architect — 5 min, 24 sec, 9% of speaking time, 13 turns
- Greg Martineau, Superintendent of Schools — 5 min, 16 sec, 8% of speaking time, 65 turns
- Kevin Wyrsch (likely), the chair — 4 min, 18 sec, 7% of speaking time, 44 turns
- Mary Coakley, Peaslee Elementary School Principal — 1 min, 44 sec, 3% of speaking time, 13 turns
- Unidentified speaker (S10), an owner's project manager representative — 1 min, 35 sec, 3% of speaking time, 11 turns
Possible Open Meeting Law issues
Any Open Meeting Law issues found for this meeting will be posted after the 30-day complaint period ends on December 2, 2026.
See the Open Meeting Law page on Mass.gov for information on the Open Meeting Law.
Summary last updated Nov 14, 2026 at 1:14 PM.