Appropriations Committee ·
Finance director warns town can't yet pay for school project and capital wish list
Appropriations Committee, October 27, 2026
Meeting summary · Northborough. Written from the meeting's automatically-generated transcripts; names come from voice recognition and may be incomplete.
Northborough's finance chief told the Appropriations Committee bluntly that "we don't know how we're going to pay for all of this." He pointed to a Peaslee School project costing the town about $70 million and $8.3 million in other capital requests that free cash won't cover. Terry Halloran pressed town leaders to start planning now for a possible Proposition 2½ override rather than waiting until spring, and also questioned why the town keeps underestimating revenue. The committee voted to recommend raising the appropriations reserve from $175,000, with members backing $350,000. It also agreed to spend its budget season on the big departments and the schools.
Capital crunch: Peaslee School, debt limits and override planning
Watch: 0:52:14–1:10:16
The most pointed exchange came when Terry Halloran pressed town leaders to work out an override strategy now. "If we are in a two and a half override situation, we don't know that for sure, but if we are, what's the strategy?" he asked (0:52:14). He wanted to know whether the town would seek a small amount, target specific departments or ask for a global override, and said the committee needed to know "December, January, rather than March."
Stephanie Bacon said the town should have most of its numbers by January (0:52:52). Terry Halloran said that would be too late: if leaders wait until January to decide, "you're going to get yourself well behind the curve." He suggested assuming a $2 million override and working out how it would be presented to voters. George Brenckle agreed the word needed to get out early "so that people can get their heads behind it earlier rather than later" (0:54:06).
Jason Little said the multi-year forecast from the town's financial summit projects a shortfall of about $5 million over five years. One option would be a single $5 million override, "and then trying to live within it for the next 5 years," though he said he didn't know if that was ideal (0:54:18). Stephanie Bacon said year-by-year overrides typically do not work (0:55:38).
Terry Halloran called the school building project "the big elephant in the room" in the capital plan and asked for a dedicated session on it soon (0:57:37). Scott Rogers agreed. Jason Little then laid out what he called "two burgeoning problems": the levy limit squeezing the operating budget, and capital costs that have "escalated greatly." Modeled at $70 million, the Peaslee School project would put the town right at its policy limit of debt equal to 10% of the budget in the first year principal comes due. That leaves little room for other borrowing (0:59:27).
Take out water and sewer funds and the Peaslee project, and the FY2028 capital requests still total about $11 million. Even after $3 million of free cash, $8.3 million is left unfunded. "I'm not coming forward with all the answers," Jason Little said (1:01:39). He added that the town's net share of Peaslee has stayed in the $70 million to $72 million range as the design evolved. Scott Rogers said the school building committee plans outreach, including a booth at the polls and messages during parent-teacher conferences (1:09:48).
- “We we don't know how we're going to pay for all of this.” — Jason Little (1:02:16)
- “Well, that's why it should be discussed as soon as possible.” — Terry Halloran (1:02:20)
- “Stephanie and Jason, this is your call as to how you think we should manage the town.” — Terry Halloran (0:55:05)
Is the town lowballing its revenue?
Watch: 0:08:33–0:34:22
As Jason Little went through the FY2026 closeout, Terry Halloran questioned why revenue beats the town's estimates by about $2 million or more every year. "I just don't get comfortable with how much we underestimate our revenue side of it and blame the state for it," he said (0:09:20).
"I don't think anybody's necessarily blaming the state, Terry," Jason Little replied (0:10:00). He said the town is "forced to be conservative." Investment income made up $1.3 million of the surplus. That came mostly from fire station bond proceeds earning interest while spending ran behind schedule, and he warned it is "not always going to be that positive." Big permit payments can't be counted until they arrive, he added, and the local receipts budget has already been raised by several hundred thousand dollars over recent years. Terry Halloran said he understood and simply wanted the committee to have "our hands around it."
Scott Rogers asked whether the state could give Northborough specific advice. Jason Little said state technical assistance would likely just validate what the town already does. Stephanie Bacon said the town is "ahead of the game" compared with other towns on reserve policies (0:17:37).
Terry Halloran also asked why property taxes came in about $700,000 short (0:18:59). Jason Little said the taxes will be collected eventually, but collections have slowed. The Supreme Court case Tyler v. Hennepin County changed Massachusetts foreclosure law. A new state rule also sets interest on tax-title parcels at about 8%, below the 14% on current bills. He called that "kind of a perverse incentive to not pay taxes." Terry Halloran asked for a report on the outstanding amount.
The same concern came back with new growth. Assessors projected $30 million in April, but $45 million was certified, which adds about $706,000 of unused levy capacity. "They were off by 50%," Terry Halloran said (0:28:38). Jason Little said the difference came mostly from personal property, which a contractor values and which wasn't finished until August after the principal assessor left in July. Many towns don't count on that figure at all, he said. Terry Halloran suggested the committee talk with the assessor during its hearings, because a $200,000 swing in the levy limit now matters.
- “normally I wouldn't care about a $200,000 delta in the levy limit, but now I think we kind of do.” — Terry Halloran (0:32:10)
- “we it will get tighter and that's what what I want to issue caution” — Jason Little (0:12:54)
Committee backs doubling the appropriations reserve
Watch: 1:10:16–1:16:39
Jason Little said the $175,000 appropriations reserve, the town's emergency cushion funded from free cash, is no longer enough, and asked whether $250,000 was reasonable (1:10:16). Last year was "egregious," he said, and if the town's levy capacity hits zero, any overspending that rolls into the next year would come out of the levy. Bids for road salt just came in 27% above last year.
Members wanted more than $250,000. Terry Halloran said treating the 2010-era figure as enough in 2026 "is just you know, it's not realistic." He settled on $350,000, double the current reserve: "I don't like to have too much cushion, but I think that this is a good use of cushion." He also noted that "we live in New England and the streets shouldn't be perfect every single time" (1:13:45). Stephanie Bacon said departments are being told to budget very lean, so "what are you going to do if there's an emergency?"
Scott Rogers said tighter department budgets need a counterweight of more flexible reserves. Terry Halloran moved to recommend that the Select Board raise the reserve from its current $175,000, with the discussion centered on $350,000. The roll call passed. Jason Little said the vote will guide the free cash plan, which goes to the Select Board once free cash is certified.
- Motion: Recommend to the Select Board that the appropriations reserve funded from free cash be increased from its current $175,000 (discussion centered on $350,000) — Passed by roll call (tally not fully captured) (1:15:43)
- “I think I would go to 300 and maybe even a little bit more.” — Terry Halloran (1:11:50)
How the committee will spend its budget season
Watch: 0:42:26–0:58:23
Scott Rogers moved this item up so George Brenckle could weigh in before leaving early. He proposed repeating last year's approach: bring in the large departments, plus any department with budget pressure, and handle small departments at or under 3% growth with written questions.
Terry Halloran agreed, saying the committee doesn't have time to judge "that $250 line item" and should focus on the big departments and the levy limit. He also wanted departments to say what they lack, citing past questions about whether the police chief is properly staffed. George Brenckle agreed: focus "on the areas where we think we can have the most impact."
a committee member asked for early preliminary numbers from the K-8 and regional school districts, saying unavoidable cost increases usually surface late. Scott Rogers said he has introduced himself to both school committees and invited school leaders to join the committee's discussions. Planned sessions include the schools (Northborough-Southborough Regional and Assabet), police, fire, DPW, an early big-picture forecast and debt review, the capital plan, and a dedicated session on the school building project.
- “if there is a question, we can raise it, and if there's not, then then we don't have to have them come in” — George Brenckle (0:48:28)
Other business
Opening business
Watch: 0:00:15–0:03:19
Scott Rogers called the remote meeting to order at 6:04 p.m. There was no public comment. Approval of the October 1 minutes was deferred because two of the members present had been absent. Terry Halloran joined shortly after.
FY2026 closeout
Watch: 0:04:35–0:26:44
The books aren't closed yet, but Jason Little said certified free cash should land almost exactly on the projected figure of about $5.3 million (0:06:59). That money funds the FY2028 capital plan. The bottom-line surplus was $2.25 million. Departments came in close to 1% under budget, which he said is uncomfortably tight in places. Terry Halloran called it "a great job of budgeting." Surpluses in health insurance helped the town absorb a 17.99% premium increase.
FY2027 update and split tax rate
Watch: 0:26:50–0:42:14
Taxable value was certified at $4.924 billion, close to projections, and the mix of residential and commercial value is essentially unchanged. The Select Board will hold its tax classification hearing later and is weighing two changes: a split tax rate, which the town has never used, and a 10% small commercial exemption. Jason Little said staff are still working out the logistics of issuing about 6,500 tax bills under a new system, and there may be challenges doing it this year.
FY2028 forecast and health insurance
Watch: 1:03:21–1:09:11
Higher new growth trimmed the projected FY2028 budget gap from $1.8 million to $1.6 million. The town is also changing health plan design and adding deductibles through the Public Employee Committee process. That could cut a forecast 12% premium increase, worth about $1.1 million, and possibly bring the gap closer to $1 million. The swing is estimated at $500,000 to $600,000 after required employee mitigation funds. Stephanie Bacon expected an agreement to be signed within a week; the actual renewal comes around February.
Terry Halloran noted that the $1.6 million gap does not include proposed firefighters, more police or the full school budget. He advised sticking with the 12% estimate for now.
Town hall repair needs (possibly not an agenda item)
Watch: 1:19:43–1:23:50
Jason Little flagged unfunded needs at the 1978 town hall: an original steam radiator system that facilities staff say is "a miracle" isn't leaking more, a roof, and ADA accessibility work. The Community Preservation Committee will discuss possible CPC-funded projects with the Financial Planning Committee. Scott Rogers asked that the projects be defined and put into the capital plan so the committee can review them.
Future meeting dates and adjournment
Watch: 1:16:39–1:27:31
The committee will meet roughly every other Tuesday at 6 p.m. through March, then weekly toward the end, avoiding the Financial Planning Committee's Thursday meetings. Next up is a joint meeting with the Select Board on November 9 at 6:30 p.m., followed tentatively by November 17. Members were asked to send in Tuesdays they can't make. The committee adjourned by roll call.
- Motion: Adjourn — Passed by roll call (1:27:01)
Who spoke
- Jason Little, Finance Director — 36 min, 29 sec, 54% of speaking time, 244 turns
- Scott Rogers, the chair — 17 min, 32 sec, 26% of speaking time, 130 turns
- Terry Halloran, a committee member — 10 min, 46 sec, 16% of speaking time, 81 turns
- Stephanie Bacon, Town Administrator — 1 min, 53 sec, 3% of speaking time, 17 turns
- George Brenckle, a committee member — 1 min, 12 sec, 2% of speaking time, 11 turns
Possible Open Meeting Law issues
Any Open Meeting Law issues found for this meeting will be posted after the 30-day complaint period ends on November 26, 2026.
See the Open Meeting Law page on Mass.gov for information on the Open Meeting Law.
Summary last updated Nov 14, 2026 at 3:06 PM.