Northborough Government News

Unofficial News from Northborough's Government Meetings

Peaslee School Building Committee ·

Peaslee building committee picks construction manager at risk despite cost and schedule questions

Peaslee School Building Committee, October 20, 2026

Meeting summary · Northborough. Written from the meeting's automatically-generated transcripts; names come from voice recognition and may be incomplete. Names in italics are likely but not yet confirmed.

The Peaslee School Building Committee voted to build the new elementary school using construction manager at risk, a method that brings a builder in during design. Supporters said it would shorten the schedule and cut change orders. Jake voted no, saying he still couldn't see how the method's extra cost would pay off. Members also backed a redesign that moves the cafeteria to the front of the school, and Mike Tietjen asked whether a simpler, boxier building could save money before what he called "a tough budget year." The project is currently estimated at $92 million to $95 million, with the town's share at roughly $72 million.

Committee chooses construction manager at risk over a traditional low-bid build

Watch: 0:25:32–1:15:40

The committee had to pick between two ways of building the school. Under design-bid-build, the town finishes the drawings, takes the lowest bid and builds. Under construction manager at risk (CM at risk), a builder joins during design, can start site work early and commits to a guaranteed maximum price. Ian Sheridan said CM at risk usually costs more but can reduce risk and speed up the schedule. A 2.7% premium came up during the discussion. Choosing CM at risk also means applying to the state Inspector General's office, which can take a couple of months.

Jake pushed back hardest. He said the team should have shown side-by-side calendars, and asked whether the method would save 2 months or 6. On a project of about $100 million, he said, the premium could mean $2.7 million, and the new school is going up behind the existing one, so students won't be moved around during construction. "So, I'm really struggling" with the advantages, he said (0:40:04). Karina Pena then showed a draft schedule: about 29 months of construction under design-bid-build, compared with 20 to 24 months under CM at risk (0:48:13). She cautioned that a real schedule would have to come from an actual construction manager.

Tristan made the case for CM at risk. He said the bidding is open book, and the town would see the bids and why firms were chosen. "No matter how good of a set of drawings we think are out there, there's always holes," he said (0:44:22). A construction manager is on the town's side to find those problems early. Ken gave examples from other projects: bolted connections instead of welded steel saved $200,000, and a framing change cut a month and about $150,000. Later Tristan added that "schedule is really important with a school," because a missed summer or vacation move-in window costs more than a delay on a fire station or library (1:07:15).

Other voices were more cautious. Greg Martineau said design-bid-build "is a method that many school districts have used to build great buildings" and that choosing it doesn't mean a poor project (0:53:06). Jason Little said the town's experience "has solely been with design-bid-build" and its projects have been successful, though the current fire station project has had delays (0:53:53). Mike Tietjen said he leaned toward CM at risk based on what he has seen on the fire station committee. He framed the choice as a question: "Is getting the low bid worth it as opposed to spending a little bit more and having more of a partnership" (0:54:43).

Ken admitted that at this stage both methods are being estimated on the same 24-month schedule, so "you still are going to pay a premium for CM" at the start. Any savings would come later, if the builder shortens the work (1:03:22). Ian Sheridan said the risk moves to the builder once the guaranteed maximum price is signed: "they're not getting more money for the project" (1:08:57).

Tristan moved to adopt CM at risk. In the roll call, Jake said he expected the motion to be "approved" but added, "I'm going to say no" (1:15:25). The motion carried.

  • Motion: Select the construction manager at risk delivery method for the Peaslee School project (moved by Tristan, seconded by Shawn) — Passed, one member voted no; full tally unclear (1:14:22)
  • “Is it going to save 2 months? Is it going to save 6 months?” — Jake (0:39:08)
  • “I don't think because you go design bid build means you're going to have a a terrible project.” — Greg Martineau (0:53:06)
  • “those disadvantages are well, what they put on those slides are aren't hypothetical. They're they're real.” — Mike Tietjen (0:55:52)

Cafeteria moves to the front, and a push to keep costs down

Watch: 1:15:56–2:01:11

Flansburgh showed a new floor plan drawn up over the weekend after a design subcommittee meeting. It swaps the gym and the cafeteria, putting the cafeteria at the front of the school and making the main entrance more prominent. Jennifer said the change would connect lunch to the playground, help with dismissal staging and make better use of the front windows. Ken said tucking the 6,000-square-foot gym into the back of the building cuts its exterior walls by about half, "which that's where the cost is" (1:58:03).

Mike Tietjen questioned the cost. He asked whether a plainer building would be cheaper: the current Peaslee's "big square," with a second floor and without the classroom pods. "Cost unfortunately is king," he said. He added that he was thinking about the April town meeting vote and "a tough budget year where probably going to be asking for an operational override" (1:43:49).

Ken answered that the layout follows the educational plan the state approved in August. Changing it would mean a different design, and the state "did not see any bells and whistles" in it (1:45:32). Kelly Guennette saw it differently: "I see it as a square with things cut out of it to save space" (1:45:54). Tristan thanked him for raising it. He urged the team to treat $92 million as a ceiling, not a target: if the estimate gets "down into the 80s. That's a win" (1:47:08).

Jake said the building's planned size has already dropped from about 76,000 square feet to about 71,000. He said the new plan is "moving in the right direction" and fixes his concern about a gym looming over the entrance (1:57:25).

On the site, the designers proposed a single one-way loop for all traffic. Buses would have their own lane, holding seven buses, and would turn around and leave without circling the campus, so no road would separate the building from the playground. Mary Coakley said she wants the outdoor basketball court near the gym for moving equipment and to keep ball noise away from classrooms. The designer said moving the court has no cost impact.

  • “I just wanted to make sure I asked the question um because I know I'm going to get asked that.” — Mike Tietjen (1:45:13)
  • “if we don't get it passed in April, then it's kind of a lot of effort for” — Tristan (1:46:23)
  • “We're not doing anything, I would say, indulgent.” — Ken (1:27:26)

Budget update: town share near $72 million, sewer costs still open

Watch: 0:02:40–0:25:31

Jenalise said the feasibility study has spent $691,763 of its $937,000 budget and is expected to stay within budget. Karina Pena went over the timeline. The schematic design is due to the Massachusetts School Building Authority (MSBA) around December 11, a project scope and budget agreement is expected in February 2027, and the town's funding votes come in April and May 2027.

Ian Sheridan said the current estimates are $95 million with CM at risk and $92 million with design-bid-build. With a 48.68% reimbursement rate, the state grant comes to about $23 million and the town's share to about $72 million. Those figures don't yet include an expected $500,000 to $700,000 from a higher reimbursement rate, or green-building incentives of 3 to 5%. Many costs fall outside state caps: building costs above $700 a square foot (early estimates topped $1,000), site work above 10% of building cost, preschool space, and any sewer or septic work.

Jake noted that Jason Little had put the maximum borrowing at $70 million: "And now we're up 2 million from that" (0:21:59). Karina Pena said the final number will likely be lower once the MSBA's update and incentives are counted, "probably be more around the 70."

Tristan called it "news" that the estimate covers only the sewer connection to the Department of Public Works (DPW) site, not the rest of the line to Main Street (0:15:59). He asked about running the line up Maple Street instead. Ken said the team will price both on-site septic and the full sewer tie-in, and both need a pump station. Northborough's DPW can't build the extra 200-foot stretch of pipe itself, so that cost will be carried in the project. He added that there is room on the site for a septic system.

  • “you really can't solidify these numbers until the MSBA gets the SD package.” — Ken (0:23:09)

Other business

Minutes approved

Watch: 0:01:01–0:02:32

Erika Hall opened the meeting at 7:01 p.m. The September 15 minutes were approved on a roll call vote.

  • Motion: Approve the September 15, 2026 meeting minutes (moved by Tristan, seconded by Kelly) — Passed (0:01:39)

Invoices approved

Watch: 2:01:11–2:02:34

Mike Tietjen said he had reviewed the invoices with a fellow member and found no issues. The committee approved them on a roll call vote. One member left at 8:25 p.m., and the committee still had a quorum.

  • Motion: Approve invoices as submitted (moved by Mike, seconded by Tristan) — Passed (2:02:05)

School district and town updates

Watch: 2:02:34–2:04:30

Greg Martineau said that, after questions from the Financial Planning Committee, the district wrote FAQs about the preschool program. It also found the May 19 meeting materials explaining why the committee picked the pre-K through grade 5 neighborhood school option. The school district update will become a standing agenda item. Jason Little had no town update. The community engagement update was folded into the subcommittee reports.

Subcommittee reports

Watch: 2:04:30–2:11:31

Kelly Guennette said the subcommittee heard "full support" at Applefest and nothing negative. Students are helping with social media, and members plan to staff a table at the upcoming election.

Kevin said a follow-up design meeting is tentatively set for next Friday.

Tristan said the subcommittee meets October 21. The state reimbursement rate has gone up. Members are comparing geothermal, air-source heat pump and variable refrigerant flow systems, with a gas boiler as backup, and the project is on track for at least LEED Silver. Ken said the MSBA's green bonuses of up to 4% are separate from federal tax credits and Mass Save rebates. None of these are included in the roughly $23 million grant figure.

December meeting moved; public comment; adjournment

Watch: 2:11:31–2:14:40

Erika Hall said the December meeting will move from December 15 to December 8 so the committee can review the schematic design before it is submitted on December 11. The November meeting stays on November 17. At the request of Kelly Guennette, a session with the Office of Campaign and Political Finance was noted as a possible future agenda item. No one spoke during public comment, and the meeting adjourned at 9:16 p.m.

  • Motion: Adjourn (moved by Kelly, seconded by Tristan) — Passed (2:14:16)

Who spoke

  • Ken (likely), the Flansburgh designer — 30 min, 52 sec, 31% of speaking time, 218 turns
  • Tristan (likely), the finance and sustainability subcommittee chair — 11 min, 10 sec, 11% of speaking time, 54 turns
  • Ian Sheridan, Project Manager, Peaslee School Project — 10 min, 34 sec, 10% of speaking time, 60 turns
  • Erika Hall (likely), the chair — 9 min, 56 sec, 10% of speaking time, 107 turns
  • Jennifer (likely), a Flansburgh designer — 8 min, 14 sec, 8% of speaking time, 74 turns
  • Karina Pena, OPM, Peasley School Project — 7 min, 51 sec, 8% of speaking time, 36 turns
  • Mike Tietjen, Select Board Vice Chair — 5 min, 35 sec, 6% of speaking time, 60 turns
  • Jake (likely), a committee member — 3 min, 56 sec, 4% of speaking time, 35 turns
  • Kelly Guennette, the communication subcommittee chair — 3 min, 55 sec, 4% of speaking time, 44 turns
  • Mary Coakley, Peaslee Elementary School Principal — 2 min, 6 sec, 2% of speaking time, 7 turns
  • Greg Martineau, Superintendent of Schools — 1 min, 59 sec, 2% of speaking time, 12 turns
  • Kevin (likely), the design subcommittee chair — 1 min, 27 sec, 1% of speaking time, 7 turns
  • Jenalise (likely), an owner's project manager representative — 1 min, 22 sec, 1% of speaking time, 14 turns
  • Unidentified speaker (S14) — 52 sec, 1% of speaking time, 14 turns
  • Jason Little, Finance Director — 45 sec, 1% of speaking time, 6 turns
  • Unidentified speaker (S16) — 20 sec, 0% of speaking time, 2 turns

Possible Open Meeting Law issues

Any Open Meeting Law issues found for this meeting will be posted after the 30-day complaint period ends on November 19, 2026.

See the Open Meeting Law page on Mass.gov for information on the Open Meeting Law.

Summary last updated Nov 14, 2026 at 3:14 PM.