Northborough Government News

Unofficial News from Northborough's Government Meetings

Select Board ·

Town Hall HVAC estimate balloons, forcing costly accessibility review as board moves on microgrid deal

Select Board, October 19, 2026

Meeting summary · Northborough. Written from the meeting's automatically-generated transcripts; names come from voice recognition and may be incomplete.

Northborough's plan to fix Town Hall's heating and cooling has fallen apart. An HVAC job that town meeting funded on a $1.3 million estimate now looks like $2.2 million to $4.3 million, and almost any renovation would trigger state accessibility rules that could add millions more. By consensus, the Select Board agreed to spend up to $90,000 from a 2012 Town Hall article so an architect can size up the accessibility work, starting with the two required restrooms and any "showstoppers." Later the board signed on to the no-cost Keep Lights On MA microgrid study, pending town counsel's review, and heard more data ahead of a Nov. 23 tax classification hearing where members are still split on shifting the tax burden to businesses.

Town Hall repair estimate misses badly; accessibility rules could add millions

Watch: 0:40:37–1:38:59

The Town Hall discussion opened as a routine update and turned into a reckoning. Scott Charpentier and Sean Thompson told the board that the planned HVAC and flooring work would trigger state accessibility (ADA) requirements. Any project over $100,000 requires at least one accessible men's room and one accessible women's room. Spending more than 30% of the building's value within any 36-month period, about $1.2 million, triggers full compliance for the whole building. Sean Thompson said that unless the town spreads the work over a decade, "there's really no way we can address any of these issues without triggering that full ADA compliance."

Jonathan Rea asked what had gone wrong. Last October the board was told the HVAC work would cost about $1.3 million, and in April 2025 town meeting approved $470,000 to close the gap. (0:59:59) "Now we're talking I mean these aren't even close," he said, calling it a miss with "huge consequence for the town." Scott Charpentier said the original design firm's detailed estimate came to about $1.9 million and carried only a 3% contingency. A peer review then found even that too low. The firm is no longer doing the estimating, he said, though its load calculations and floor plans remain usable. (1:00:26)

The peer review priced a long-life air-to-water heat pump system, which would retire steam piping Sean Thompson called "86 years past its useful life," at up to $4.3 million. A VRF system came in around $3.5 million. Both would need a costly electrical service upgrade. A third, replace-in-kind option is roughly $2.2 million, though that figure was only verbal. The town has about $1.3 million on hand: roughly $672,000 and $189,000 left in two 2012 articles, plus the $470,000 from 2025. Sean Thompson guessed the full ADA work alone could reach $4 to $5 million and stressed that this was a guess. (1:12:19)

Flooring brought its own surprise. A $150,000 carpet figure had been mentioned before. A designer's rough estimate is now $400,000 to $650,000 before furniture moving, and Scott Charpentier said he was "dumbfounded" that flooring counts toward the ADA trigger. Sean Thompson ranked carpet low on his priority list even though it dates to 1978: "I'm not going to be a popular guy in the building tomorrow because I just said that out loud." (1:19:35)

Jonathan Rea asked about seeking a variance from the Architectural Access Board. Scott Charpentier said variances are hard to win but agreed to explore one. He also agreed to rescope the $90,000 architect contract with Icon so it first prices the two restrooms and flags any major structural "showstoppers" before the rest of the money is spent. Leslie Rutan supported moving ahead with the architect. By consensus, the board authorized the $90,000 from the 2012 Town Hall improvements article. Staff will return Nov. 23 with the third HVAC option, the flooring estimate and the first ADA findings. The study takes eight to nine weeks, and staff will also look at Community Preservation funding, which has an application date around Nov. 1. (1:38:15)

  • Motion: Consensus to authorize up to $90,000 from the 2012 Town Hall improvements article for an architect's ADA schematic design and cost estimate, rescoped to start with the two required restrooms and major structural issues — Approved by consensus (no formal vote) (1:38:15)
  • “as soon as we saw a detailed estimate, we identified that as a problem, hit the brakes immediately” — Scott Charpentier (1:00:26)
  • “This is complicated. Like there's a lot of things we don't know” — Jonathan Rea (1:34:31)
  • “I generally like to come with answers and directions, but in this case, I think it was important that we just came with information” — Scott Charpentier (1:38:40)

Keep Lights On MA: board joins microgrid study, pending legal review

Watch: 1:55:05–2:47:40

Gina Ash, a Harvard resident, presented by Zoom and invited Northborough to become the sixth town in a consortium with Harvard, Shirley, Ayer, Lancaster and Bolton. The towns would each host "hero hub" microgrids of up to 10 megawatts: solar, batteries and smart controls at critical sites that could disconnect from the grid during outages. The state has awarded a first $1 million tranche, through Harvard, of a possible $5 million grant for feasibility studies.

Her pitch: investors would finance about $30 million per town. Ownership would "flip" to the towns in year five. Municipal electricity costs could drop up to 50% from day one, and surplus power could bring in about $1 million a year on average over 20 years. Jason Little said the town spent $285,000 on electricity for town buildings and $275,000 for schools in FY26. Ricardo ? said towns would contribute 20-year land leases rather than cash. (2:22:31)

Mike Tietjen confirmed the memorandum of understanding is non-binding. Kimberly ? said there are go/no-go decision points along the way. Jonathan Rea asked whether the company is owned by private equity. Ricardo ? said the three executives are the sole owners, and Kimberly ? added, "We've been volunteers." Jonathan Rea asked for low, base and best-case projections. Mike Tietjen asked who would maintain and eventually remove the equipment. The company said the fund's operating entity would handle maintenance, and Kimberly ? said decommissioning costs would be "contemplated in the in the ultimate fund." (2:43:08)

Gina Ash said people "typically respond that this sounds too good to be true," and credited the consortium's scale for making it work. Leslie Rutan called it "an interesting concept." (2:28:55)

After the motion was made, Mike Tietjen pointed out that town counsel wanted "non-binding" added to the MOU. Gina Ash said the document is locked because the other towns have already signed it. Jonathan Rea said "this isn't a delay tactic" and proposed approving it pending town counsel's advice. The motion was amended that way and approved.

  • Motion: Approve the memorandum of understanding for the Keep Lights On MA initiative and authorize Jonathan Rea to sign it for the town, pending town counsel's advice on the language — Approved by roll call; tally not clear in captions (2:45:12)
  • “we're not asking the towns to put up $30 million per town” — Gina Ash (2:07:02)
  • “if we're not committing ourselves if we sign the memorandum of understanding” — Leslie Rutan (2:28:40)

Tax classification: new data, old split over shifting the burden

Watch: 2:47:40–3:44:57

Jason Little presented without the principal assessor. The state has certified $45 million in new growth, not the $30 million the town had estimated. That raises new levy capacity from $445,000 to $668,000 and trims the projected budget gap from roughly $1.85 to $2 million to about $1.6 million. Commercial, industrial and personal property make up 25.93% of total value. A 10% shift toward business would cut residential bills by about 3.5% and raise business bills by 10%. Medians changed the picture: the median commercial parcel is $898,000 against a $2.4 million average.

The board's split showed again. Jonathan Rea said the maximum shift would be "huge increases" that he doesn't think anyone is considering. But even a 10% shift is "a meaningful number," he said, adding, "I don't think you need to go draconian." He argued that residential and commercial properties are assessed by different methods, and that businesses can deduct taxes as an expense. (3:11:45)

Mike Tietjen countered that a shift doesn't fix anything wrong with valuations and that higher taxes eventually lower commercial values, so "in order to get the same effect you have to continue to shift it." Julianne Hirsh said that for her "it's also a fairness thing," even if the effect on bills is small. Members agreed that apartment buildings are taxed as residential, and that rents follow the market more than tax rates. (3:12:45)

On the small commercial exemption, Jason Little urged caution. Thirteen of 352 communities use it, and all of them also split their rates. It goes to building owners with no more than 10 employees and buildings under $1 million. As many as 111 of the town's 200 commercial parcels fall under that value cap, and state officials advised a long lead time. Jonathan Rea called it "a gesture of good will" and asked staff to contact towns that use it.

Julianne Hirsh suggested holding the hearing over two meetings. Mike Tietjen and Leslie Rutan preferred a single hearing on Nov. 23, with public comment open until then. Tax bills must go out by the end of December.

  • “every community that kind of goes down this path once you start shifting more” — Mike Tietjen (3:12:13)
  • “for me it's also a fairness thing” — Julianne Hirsh (3:13:59)

Peasley project: chair presses for pre-K enrollment data

Watch: 3:52:25–4:07:39

Mike Tietjen said the building committee meets remotely tomorrow at 7 p.m. Angie Sowden pointed residents to the project's web page, a homepage link and a Facebook page.

Jonathan Rea asked for about 10 years of data on how many pre-K seats the district is legally required to provide for students with IEPs versus seats open to other families. He said he'd heard conflicting accounts, and that people have told him "John doesn't support this." His answer: "well, I'd like to see data." With the pre-K piece costing about $10 million, he said, "a sharp pencil I think residents will appreciate." (3:57:47)

Mike Tietjen explained that the project only replaces existing space: five classrooms, two of which Southborough is reclaiming. Classrooms built at Peasley qualify for state MSBA reimbursement, while new space elsewhere would not. The program is roughly 50% IEP students. He questioned how much historical enrollment would matter to the decision but agreed to ask the superintendent. He also urged colleagues to email Peasley questions to him rather than wait for a meeting where "I don't have the answers and then you're like, 'Aha.'" (4:04:38) Jonathan Rea said he would send a detailed email.

  • “It is simply space for what we're doing now.” — Mike Tietjen (4:05:14)
  • “I don't know how pertinent that to whether or not it's appropriate to add prek to the Peasley project” — Mike Tietjen (3:58:26)

Other business

Opening, public comment and firefighter swearing-in

Watch: 0:01:02–0:10:11

Amy Clark asked the board to propose bylaws on Amazon drone deliveries, noting that Westborough is acting and Shrewsbury is drafting bylaws.

Keith Darling introduced firefighters Drew Gage and Zachary Ashman, and Daymian Bartek swore them in.

BJ's package store manager change

Watch: 0:10:11–0:13:17

The board approved Arthur McMahon as manager of BJ's all-alcohol package store license, subject to state ABCC approval.

  • Motion: Approve change of manager to Arthur McMahon for the Mormax Corp. d/b/a BJ's Wholesale Club all-alcohol package store license, subject to ABCC approval — Approved by roll call; tally not clear in captions (0:12:21)

Revolution 250 Committee recap

Watch: 0:13:17–0:26:08

Norm Corbin said the committee will dissolve at the end of December. Bob Licht reported funding from ARPA ($9,000), CPA (about $9,000 for a Revolutionary War monument) and free cash ($15,000). About $4,000 will go back to the town. The monument dedication is Nov. 14.

The committee has made 25 videos. Its research also found that the Northborough Tea Party happened three months after Boston's, not before as long claimed.

Safe Routes to School grant

Watch: 0:26:08–0:40:37

Keith Lavoie said the town submitted a $1.9 million application on Oct. 15, a day before the deadline, with designs complete. It covers sidewalks on Maple Street from Ridge Road to Bartlett Street (the priority) and on Pleasant, Church and Howard streets. A decision is expected by Thanksgiving.

Scott Charpentier said the sidewalks would be 5 feet wide and need no easements. Bidding would happen in winter, with construction after spring town meeting.

Prior-year capital funds and which pot pays

Watch: 1:39:19–1:55:05

Jason Little said leftover money from older capital articles could go toward the voter-approved Zeh School roof debt. That would require a town meeting vote and notice to the MSBA.

Members then debated which account should cover the $90,000 ADA study. Jonathan Rea preferred the April 2025 HVAC money so the roughly $690,000 left from 2012 could return to free cash "really transparent." Jason Little favored using the oldest money first, calling it "egregiously old money," but said he wouldn't "die on the hill either way." Mike Tietjen preferred the 2012 money so the 2025 funds stay with HVAC as town meeting intended. Leslie Rutan sided with 2012, and the original decision stood.

Open Meeting Law complaint response

Watch: 3:44:57–3:52:23

The board approved town counsel's response to Patrick Higgins' complaint. Agendas will now list reports more specifically, and members will take a 90-minute training. Mike Tietjen joked that members may have to "participate in our own public comment" to make general announcements.

  • Motion: Approve the Oct. 19 response letter to the Open Meeting Law complaint and authorize submission to the Attorney General's Division of Open Government — Approved by roll call; tally not clear in captions (3:51:53)

Amended Sept. 10 financial summit minutes

Watch: 4:07:39–4:09:08

The minutes were amended to add school committee member Erin Tagliaferri as an attendee.

  • Motion: Approve amended Sept. 10, 2026 financial summit minutes — Approved by roll call; tally not clear in captions (4:08:42)

Amazon Prime Air drone update

Watch: 4:09:08–4:18:14

Jonathan Rea read a memo saying Westborough is coordinating a regional letter that supports federal lawmakers' call for an FAA site-specific review. Members backed signing it and possibly sending their own "strong" letter. They will hold a brief remote meeting if needed before Nov. 9.

Leslie Rutan, the planning board liaison, will ask the planning board to consider drone bylaws.

Reports, public comment and future agenda

Watch: 4:18:14–4:26:56

Mike Tietjen said overnight roadwork for the fire station project should finish by the end of the month. Leslie Rutan reported that the school committee will move its meetings to the library in January.

There was no public comment. Upcoming: a joint budget meeting Nov. 9, the tax hearing and legislators Nov. 23, and license renewals and the voting location in December. The meeting adjourned.

Who spoke

  • Jason Little, Finance Director — 39 min, 2 sec, 19% of speaking time, 254 turns
  • Jonathan Rea, Select Board Chair — 36 min, 54 sec, 18% of speaking time, 340 turns
  • Gina Ash, Chief Commercial Officer, NextGen Energy — 23 min, 56 sec, 11% of speaking time, 110 turns
  • Sean Thompson, Facility manager — 21 min, 29 sec, 10% of speaking time, 106 turns
  • Scott Charpentier, Public Works Director — 20 min, 37 sec, 10% of speaking time, 152 turns
  • Mike Tietjen, Select Board Vice Chair — 17 min, 14 sec, 8% of speaking time, 126 turns
  • Leslie Rutan, Select Board Member — 9 min, 19 sec, 4% of speaking time, 97 turns
  • Angie Sowden, Executive Assistant — 7 min, 25 sec, 4% of speaking time, 52 turns
  • Kimberly ?, Nextgen Energy — 7 min, 7 sec, 3% of speaking time, 22 turns
  • Julianne Hirsh, Select Board Member — 4 min, 49 sec, 2% of speaking time, 76 turns
  • Bob Licht, the committee secretary — 4 min, 40 sec, 2% of speaking time, 28 turns
  • Ricardo ?, NextGen Energy — 4 min, 26 sec, 2% of speaking time, 12 turns
  • Norm Corbin, the committee chair — 4 min, 23 sec, 2% of speaking time, 31 turns
  • Keith Lavoie, Assistant Superintendent of Operations — 4 min, 21 sec, 2% of speaking time, 12 turns
  • Keith Darling, Fire Chief — 1 min, 54 sec, 1% of speaking time, 6 turns
  • Amy Clark, a Main Street resident — 1 min, 15 sec, 1% of speaking time, 15 turns
  • Daymian Bartek, Town Clerk — 44 sec, 0% of speaking time, 16 turns
  • Diane Wackell, Assistant Town Administrator — 36 sec, 0% of speaking time, 9 turns

Possible Open Meeting Law issues

Any Open Meeting Law issues found for this meeting will be posted after the 30-day complaint period ends on November 18, 2026.

See the Open Meeting Law page on Mass.gov for information on the Open Meeting Law.

Summary last updated Nov 14, 2026 at 12:35 PM.