Combined School Committee ·
Regional school panel flags capital math error as towns press for lean FY28 budget
Combined School Committee, October 7, 2026
Meeting summary · Northborough. Written from the meeting's automatically-generated transcripts; names come from voice recognition and may be incomplete.
At a 7:30 a.m. joint meeting of the Algonquin regional budget and capital subcommittees, a member caught a spreadsheet error: the proposed FY28 capital list adds up to about $460,000, not the $645,000 shown. The biggest item is replacing a broken cafeteria heating unit, and the high school is heading into winter with that unit offline. District leaders said both Northborough and Southborough have told schools to budget within tight limits. Northborough also wants a 3% scenario. Leaders are counting on about $600,000 in health-insurance savings and an $800,000-or-more drop in debt payments to ease next year's town assessments.
FY28 capital list: a math error, leaking pipes and a dead cafeteria unit
Watch: 0:02:41–0:22:47
Greg Martineau started by explaining the committee's capital strategy. Algonquin Regional High School was renovated in 2004 and covers 350,000 square feet. The plan is to spend about $400,000 a year on ongoing repairs and handle roofs, windows and paving as separate, larger projects. He said the approach has "served the district well" over its two years.
Keith Lavoie had barely begun presenting five FY28 projects totaling $645,000 when Matt Spencer cut in: "I can't help myself." (0:05:21) By his math the listed items added up to $460,000, not $645,000. He also noted the cafeteria rooftop unit appeared as $35,000 on the spreadsheet but $150,000 in the write-up. Keith Lavoie agreed the spreadsheet was "not summing properly" and said, "So that's my error. Thank you." (0:06:53)
The projects are two-way radios to begin security upgrades at the high school, a second year of building envelope and waterproofing work, $150,000 to replace leaking fittings on the heating loop, $30,000 to bring the glycol (antifreeze) level in that system back toward 35%, and replacement of a failed cafeteria rooftop unit. Greg Martineau added that the district won a $50,000 grant through legislative advocacy for valve work. It must be spent by the end of FY27. (0:10:48)
Members asked about the radios. About 50 units would replace every radio at the high school. Keith Lavoie said the system ties into first responders, can link "all 10 schools" and gets coverage within about a mile of the campuses. (0:13:28)
The cafeteria unit drew the most follow-up questions. Keith Lavoie said it is offline now. The cafeteria is running on its second 25-year-old unit, which works but carries a heavier load than it was designed for. Matt Spencer asked whether that unit failing this winter could close school. (0:19:21) "Probably not," Keith Lavoie said. The district would do an emergency procurement to repair it. Greg Martineau said that could mean renting emergency heat, "which we'd like to avoid." He added that this is "just one of many" rooftop units, which is why the district wants a plan to replace them before a crisis. (0:19:59)
Matt Spencer also asked whether rooftop units should be replaced together with roofs. Staff said roofs can accommodate new equipment. Contracts would have the roofing contractor inspect the work so warranties stay intact.
- “So the math isn't the math is not right.” — Matt Spencer (0:06:06)
- “So, at currently that unit is is offline.” — Keith Lavoie (0:18:59)
- “have a plan and move through that plan um in a proactive manner.” — Greg Martineau (0:19:59)
Using the debt drop to keep town assessments flat
Watch: 0:22:50–0:30:02
Looking at the 10-year plan, Keith Lavoie said the big future costs are roof replacements, which can be done one section at a time, parking lot reclamation and the building's major rooftop units. An engineer will help put the units in sequence. (0:23:05)
Becky Pellegrino said this is the last year of debt payments on the high school renovation. Starting in FY28, the towns will instead pay the full debt on the athletic complex, which was permanently financed this summer. That debt is lower, "at least a um $800,000" difference overall. (0:25:21) Greg Martineau said the strategy has been to hold off on large projects until the renovation debt is paid. When to take on larger projects, given the towns' finances, will be a question for the full committee.
Matt Spencer proposed a multi-year approach. With about $27 million in capital needs on the horizon, he suggested using the gap before any big project to "pull forward" smaller capital items. That would keep the assessment flat while work gets done, then the district would "roll into the bigger one." (0:27:38) Staff answered, "Yes. Yep."
Greg Martineau called the numbers a first draft. Corrections will come to the October regional committee meeting. He also wants to present the plan to Northborough and Southborough boards ahead of the spring town meetings.
- “we should want to pull forward some of the other items from the annual capital project so that we keep the the the assessment flat year-over-year” — Matt Spencer (0:27:38)
- “what is the right timing for larger capital projects at Algangan Regional High School given the context of the town's” — Greg Martineau (0:25:33)
Towns ask for level-funded and 3% budgets as district warns of limits
Watch: 0:30:02–0:47:32
Greg Martineau described both towns facing "almost identical" pressures. Budget growth can no longer be covered within the Proposition 2½ levy limit, which raises fears of override votes. The FY27 regional assessment rose 5.81% because of health care, transportation, electricity and special education costs. That came even as the district cut 5.5 full-time positions, and it has cut a double-digit number over three years. (0:31:23) He said the district is at "an inflection point." Further cuts through attrition would be hard to make without affecting class-size policy and electives. (0:32:09)
Becky Pellegrino listed what is driving costs: volatile energy supplier prices, health insurance, special education transportation and out-of-district tuition. Inflation is rising again, with suppliers adding fuel surcharges. Operating budget increases have averaged just over 4% a year for eight years. (0:40:36)
Both towns have given direction. Southborough wants a level-services budget, with non-salary lines based on FY26 actual spending, plus a level-funded version. Northborough wants the same plus a scenario showing what cuts it would take to reach 3% if level services comes in higher. (0:43:39) Becky Pellegrino said a level-funded budget would "definitely" mean cuts to services, because contract costs are fixed.
On savings, the district is leading talks with both towns on restructuring health plans to mirror the state's Group Insurance Commission. That could add deductibles to HMO plans. A committee including union members and a retiree will meet, and part of the savings would be shared with members. Greg Martineau put the regional savings at "about 600" in FY28 and aims to finish by late November or early December. (0:38:54)
Timeline: leadership budget sheets are due Oct. 20. A preliminary budget comes Nov. 18, earlier than usual because of Southborough's schedule. A recommended budget is due in January and a committee vote in February. Town meetings are March 20 in Southborough and April 26, 2027, in Northborough. Joan Frank said: "Can't believe we're starting already so soon."
- “I think we are at an inflection point where uh those reductions that we've made through attrition are going to be even more challenging” — Greg Martineau (0:32:09)
- “we would definitely be looking at some some sort of um cuts to our services” — Becky Pellegrino (0:41:22)
Other business
Call to order
Watch: 0:00:09–0:00:23
Erin Tagliaferri called the joint meeting of the Operational Budget and Capital Planning subcommittees to order. Greg Martineau then moved the capital discussion ahead of the budget items.
FY28 budget priorities
Watch: 0:47:35–0:57:14
Becky Pellegrino presented draft priorities aligned with the Vision 2032 strategic plan. They are to sustain high-quality, equitable instruction, partner with both towns on health care costs, strengthen communications, plan for special education costs and develop a five-year financial outlook. She proposed asking both town meetings to approve warrant articles creating a special education stabilization fund. (0:50:33)
Matt Spencer suggested dropping the push for a communications position. He said funding for that role is "unlikely given the environment." (0:52:00) Greg Martineau proposed writing a communications plan instead, with costs projected over five years.
Greg Martineau cautioned that the committee controls the overall budget increase but not each town's assessment. The assessment depends on a complex formula that enrollment and wealth factors "can wildly shift." He recommended focusing on the overall increase rather than trying to minimize assessments. (0:55:27) Erin Tagliaferri said "I don't think that was very clear", and Joan Frank joked, "Can I have the cliff notes?" The priorities will likely go to the regional committee in two weeks.
FY27 capital project status
Watch: 0:01:03–0:02:41
Becky Pellegrino reported that the FY27 technology work and the grounds tractor replacement are done. Still in progress are sidewalk and curb repairs ($65,000, with spring work expected after an engineer's plan), a theater ADA chairlift ($55,000), a wood shop dust collector ($45,000) and weatherproofing ($30,000).
Adjournment
Watch: 0:57:20–0:58:11
The subcommittees adjourned by roll call. Joan Frank said she needed to talk with staff afterward about a bus issue that morning on Whitney Street.
- Motion: Motion to adjourn — Passed by roll call (count unclear) (0:57:35)
Who spoke
- Becky Pellegrino, School District Finance Director — 14 min, 52 sec, 34% of speaking time, 52 turns
- Greg Martineau, Superintendent of Schools — 12 min, 8 sec, 28% of speaking time, 94 turns
- Keith Lavoie, Assistant Superintendent of Operations — 9 min, 35 sec, 22% of speaking time, 38 turns
- Matt Spencer, a subcommittee member — 5 min, 14 sec, 12% of speaking time, 39 turns
- Erin Tagliaferri, the subcommittee chair — 1 min, 2 sec, 2% of speaking time, 21 turns
- Joan Frank, Regional School Committee Chair — 54 sec, 2% of speaking time, 11 turns
Possible Open Meeting Law issues
Potential issues to consider, not legal determinations. Complaint deadline: November 6, 2026.
During the meeting
- 0:00:00 Not announcing at the start that the meeting was being recorded.
- 0:00:00 Not announcing which members were participating remotely at the start of a fully remote meeting.
- 0:05:00 Combined School Committee's minutes may omit the capital spreadsheet and screen-shared budget presentations used at the meeting.
See the Open Meeting Law page on Mass.gov for information on the Open Meeting Law.
Summary last updated Nov 14, 2026 at 3:00 PM.