Northborough Government News

Unofficial News from Northborough's Government Meetings

Peaslee School Building Committee Finance and Sustainability Subcommittee ·

School building panel weighs gas backup against lost tax credits for heating

Peaslee School Building Committee Finance and Sustainability Subcommittee, September 30, 2026

Meeting summary · Northborough. Written from the meeting's automatically-generated transcripts; names come from voice recognition and may be incomplete. Names in italics are likely but not yet confirmed.

At its first meeting, the Peaslee School Building Committee's new finance and sustainability subcommittee asked engineers to study a natural gas option for the new 71,000-square-foot school, even after being warned that gas could cost the town federal tax credits and a 3% state reimbursement bonus. Members also got their first look at choosing between a construction manager at risk and traditional design-bid-build, which comes with an estimated $2.7 million in extra cost, ahead of a vote expected before the December state submission. Along the way the committee heard that the state building authority raised its funding by $22 per square foot, and asked how much of the pre-K space the state will pay for.

Heating options, and whether to keep gas on the table

Watch: 0:22:52–1:15:34

Matthew Woodward laid out three heating and cooling systems his firm plans to compare in a life-cycle cost analysis. Option A is a geothermal wellfield with displacement ventilation, which he called "the Cadillac": the highest first cost and the lowest energy use. Option B uses air-source heat pumps. Option C, a VRF system, would likely have the lowest first cost. He then asked whether the group wanted a natural gas option studied too, since nothing in code prohibits it.

Tristan Bazant said yes: "we should study everything" at this stage rather than later. He also asked for end-of-life replacement and maintenance costs to be counted. Mike Tietjen agreed the gas option should be studied "so we're covering all options," and asked where the equipment is made given "global turmoil." Matthew Woodward said tariff exposure would probably be highest for the VRF option (0:36:40). Later Tristan Bazant argued for a gas backup boiler because it is more efficient than an electric one and needs a much smaller emergency generator (0:44:19).

Kent pushed back hard (0:45:12). If gas is introduced, he said, "you're going to contaminate" the system for Inflation Reduction Act credits, and he said one past project's eligibility fell to $1.8 million because of a backup boiler. Matthew Woodward added that a gas connection would also keep the school from meeting the opt-in stretch energy code, which triggers the MSBA's 3% bonus: "no one doesn't want 3%" on a project worth millions. He said a gas boiler on the geothermal option would cost the project tax credits, though he could see it as a backup on Option B.

Mike Tietjen asked about emergency backup. The generator, likely around 400 kW, would run on diesel. He floated running a gas generator on neighboring town DPW property to feed the school; Kent said the school site can't have a gas line but it was "something we can evaluate." The consultants also said modern heat pumps can heat down to about -22 degrees and that the wellfield could be operating from the first day without disrupting the existing school.

Jason Little explained how rebates would be handled. The town would borrow short-term, then use rebates to retire the notes rather than take on long-term debt, and any rebates would have to go toward the excluded debt, not the general fund. Matthew Woodward closed by saying GGD will add an "Option D": Option B with a gas boiler backup. Members asked for Mass Save incentives in real dollars for each option. On noise and looks, Kent said the geothermal option would have the least impact on neighbors.

  • “I would not advocate a gas boiler on option A” — Matthew Woodward (0:46:22)
  • “welcome to the new world” — Kent (0:50:23)
  • “we wouldn't lock into a long-term debt obligation” — Jason Little (1:07:58)

Construction manager at risk or design-bid-build

Watch: 1:35:03–1:56:34

Karina Pena said the full building committee will need to vote on a delivery method before the December submission to the MSBA, and offered to resend earlier slides so members can prepare.

Mike Tietjen asked whether the estimated extra cost of a construction manager at risk, about $2.7 million, was a conservative figure. Kent called it realistic for the region. He said a CM might shorten the typical 24-month schedule to around 20 months and win back some of that cost, but that savings is not factored in.

He walked through the timeline. Schematic design goes to the state on December 10, the CM procurement process (which needs a state response, sometimes 60 days) starts in January, and a CM would come on board about two weeks after the April town vote. A CM's preconstruction work would challenge the design team, check the estimate and split the work into early bid packages, such as the geothermal field and the town sewer connection.

Tristan Bazant noted that CM firms often deeply discount preconstruction fees, which have run from about $75,000 to $250,000, because "they make money" on construction. He described the process as iterative, not "one shot." Rob called it "more transparent" and collaborative. Kent said he is "50/50" in general, but that the geothermal work, sewer connection and occupied school site lean this project toward a CM. Karina Pena said the project manager is comfortable with either choice and that a vote is planned for the next meeting.

  • “That's pretty realistic based on our estimators” — Kent (1:37:59)
  • “We're working towards that final number. That is our target.” — Tristan Bazant (1:51:20)

Pre-K reimbursement and what the state won't pay for

Watch: 2:05:33–2:16:47

Tristan Bazant asked whether the state-mandated pre-K space is reimbursed at the same rate as K-5. Karina Pena said pre-K is not MSBA-reimbursable. Kent said the five pre-K classrooms themselves are eligible, but an extra office and OT/PT space for pre-K probably are not.

Mike Tietjen said Select Board colleagues keep asking about the roughly $9-10 million pre-K estimate, and asked for a reimbursable figure. Kent worked it out at about 1,788 gross square feet per 1,200-square-foot classroom and agreed to follow up by email with the cost per square foot.

Kent warned that the roughly 48% reimbursement rate applies only to eligible costs, "not half the cost of the project." Exclusions include asbestos removal, underground tanks, excess space and furniture above about $1,800 per student. The MSBA's eligibility decisions are expected around February.

  • “it's not straight 48% off of the construction value” — Kent (2:14:32)
  • “the ineligible items are really important because that comes down to your bottom line” — Kent (2:16:23)

Other business

Opening and subcommittee chair

Watch: 0:00:13–0:04:22

Karina Pena opened the meeting and reviewed the charge: advising the building committee on financial projections and sustainability. Members elected Tristan Bazant chair on a motion by Mike Tietjen. The vice chair vote was held until Jake joined.

  • Motion: Elect Tristan Bazant subcommittee chair — Passed 3-0 (roll call) (0:03:05)

Mass Save incentives from National Grid

Watch: 0:05:12–0:22:45

Lexi Zabo described three incentive paths for new construction, which must be all-electric to qualify. Under the net-zero path, a K-12 school with an energy-use target of 22 would get $1.25 per square foot, plus $1.50 per square foot after a year of metered results. The second path pays 50 cents to $1 per square foot depending on energy savings, and the third pays measure by measure. A heat pump bonus would, for example, pay $16,000 for 20 tons of air-source heat pumps, with more for ground-source.

Eileen Barrett said ground-source projects have earned substantial incentives. Colleen Soden said demand-response programs saved Arlington High School $125,000-$150,000. Officials confirmed the presentation can be posted publicly.

LEED and sustainability goals

Watch: 1:15:34–1:35:03

Colleen Soden said the project is tracking about 60 LEED points: comfortably silver, the MSBA minimum, with a possible reach for gold. Five of seven material credits could earn an extra 1% MSBA reimbursement. She estimated at least a quarter million dollars in Mass Save incentives. Other plans include MERV 13 filtration, displacement ventilation, enhanced commissioning, rainwater management, and building-as-teaching-tool ties to the Museum of Science's YES program. Next steps: another meeting in mid-October, the MSBA submission in December and the town vote in April.

MSBA funding increase

Watch: 1:56:34–1:58:52

Karina Pena reported that the MSBA raised its funding limit by $22 per square foot. That could mean $500,000 to $700,000 more, depending on final square footage. Jason Little confirmed it changes the town's financial plan, and the two will update the numbers.

Vice chair, scheduling and one-story question

Watch: 1:58:53–2:05:33

Jake was elected vice chair on a motion by Rob. The next meeting is proposed for the week of October 13; Karina Pena will email a date. Kent reported that a one-story design, raised by a School Building Committee member, would cost more because of extra foundation, roofing and stormwater work. A formal response will follow.

  • Motion: Elect Jake vice chair of the subcommittee — Passed 4-0 (roll call) (2:00:08)

Public comment and adjournment

Watch: 2:16:51–2:17:36

There was no public comment, and the meeting adjourned.

  • Motion: Adjourn — Passed 4-0 (roll call) (2:16:51)

Who spoke

  • Kent (likely), an architect team representative — 27 min, 8 sec, 27% of speaking time, 286 turns
  • Matthew Woodward (likely), the GGD HVAC engineer — 17 min, 36 sec, 17% of speaking time, 199 turns
  • Colleen Soden (likely), the sustainability consultant — 15 min, 49 sec, 16% of speaking time, 74 turns
  • Karina Pena, OPM, Peasley School Project — 11 min, 21 sec, 11% of speaking time, 67 turns
  • Tristan Bazant (likely), the subcommittee chair — 7 min, 37 sec, 8% of speaking time, 50 turns
  • Lexi Zabo (likely), a National Grid program representative — 6 min, 51 sec, 7% of speaking time, 32 turns
  • Mike Tietjen, Select Board Vice Chair — 4 min, 56 sec, 5% of speaking time, 54 turns
  • Jake (likely), a subcommittee member — 2 min, 36 sec, 3% of speaking time, 20 turns
  • Eileen Barrett (likely), a National Grid program manager — 2 min, 19 sec, 2% of speaking time, 16 turns
  • Rob (likely), a building committee vice chair — 2 min, 15 sec, 2% of speaking time, 26 turns
  • Jason Little, Finance Director — 1 min, 46 sec, 2% of speaking time, 11 turns
  • Unidentified speaker (S12) — 30 sec, 0% of speaking time, 8 turns

Possible Open Meeting Law issues

Potential issues to consider, not legal determinations. Complaint deadline: October 30, 2026.

Agenda

  • The agenda's catch-all 'New business that may properly come before the Committee' heading failed to specifically disclose the vice-chair vote, a one-story building cost inquiry, and preK/MSBA reimbursement rate discussion. Discussed at 2:03:00.

During the meeting

  • 0:00:00 Failing to announce at the start of the meeting that it was being recorded, with the recording only acknowledged informally about 22 minutes in by a non-chair presenter.
  • 0:02:00 Not listing the election of chair and vice chair on the meeting agenda despite evidence the chair selection had been discussed in advance.

See the Open Meeting Law page on Mass.gov for information on the Open Meeting Law.

Summary last updated Nov 14, 2026 at 5:27 PM.