Historic District Commission ·
Burial ground labyrinth put off a year over $125,000 estimate; church steeple wins backing
Historic District Commission, September 16, 2026
Meeting summary · Northborough. Written from the meeting's automatically-generated transcripts; names come from voice recognition and may be incomplete. Names in italics are likely but not yet confirmed.
A plan for a walkable stone labyrinth at the Brigham Street Burial Ground was put off until 2027. Commissioners said they were shocked by a town-adjusted estimate of about $125,000 and unsure about prevailing wage rules, who should lead the project and which funding category it belongs in. Earlier, the Historic District Commission voted unanimously to back Trinity Church's request for a $265,000 Community Preservation Act grant to finish repairs on its 178-year-old steeple. The steeple's spire and bell were taken down in March and are sitting in the church parking lot until the work is done.
Labyrinth proposal tabled after sticker shock
Watch: 0:45:25–1:29:14
Diane Smith brought back her plan for a 60-foot walkable labyrinth at the Brigham Street Burial Ground. She said its concentric circles take their cue from the carvings on Joseph Wheeler's gravestone, and a compass design would sit at the center. She had marked the layout on the grass with spray paint and walked the site with Scott, a town official who has been consulted on the project. Her own breakdown of the costs came to roughly $48,000 to $55,000. After Scott added prevailing wage and other municipal costs, the figure rose to about $125,000.
Leslie Harrison opened with concern. She said she had "serious sticker shock" and questioned the plan for three rows of cobblestones instead of the one or two discussed before. At (0:57:14) she pointed out that the cobble line was $13,600 in one estimate and about $45,000 in Scott's. Diane Smith explained that Scott's figure includes installation. She said three courses would make the labyrinth close to zero-maintenance for the town because no one would need to weed-whack it, but that two courses would work fine at this size.
Prevailing wage became the central question. Diane Smith said she understood it came with CPA money. Tom Reirden said the trigger is more likely that this is construction on town property. He noted that the CPA-funded steeple and Historical Society window projects were not prevailing wage jobs, and said appeals might be possible. Diane Smith said that as a contractor she "wouldn't have been anywhere near this number." At (1:07:03) Leslie Harrison reported that her quick search confirmed that town property is what triggers prevailing wage.
Members suggested ways to bring the cost down: two courses of cobble instead of three, hydroseed instead of sod (which Diane Smith estimated would save close to $4,000), and splitting the project into phases. Tom Reirden suggested asking about exemptions or negotiating with unions. He also noted that any phase paid for with private fundraising rather than CPC money would not carry prevailing wage.
Bob Licht raised the question of who would carry the project. The application is "involved," he said, and "it's really going to require a person full-time." Members also could not agree on whether it falls under historic preservation, open space or passive recreation. They noted that the recreation department has its own big skate park project. After Diane Smith left, Bob Licht said he got the documents "15 minutes before the meeting started," could not read half of them, and has no time before the October deadline because of the Trinity letter and the Revolutionary War monument.
Members agreed they could not meet the end-of-October CPC deadline and voted at (1:28:18) to table the project for a possible 2027 submission. Leslie Harrison pushed for the work to keep moving anyway: "otherwise we're going to end up in a year from now and say we're not ready again." Diane Smith will go back to Scott to reprice the plan with two courses and hydroseed and to ask about prevailing wage.
- Motion: Table the Brigham Street Burial Ground labyrinth project for possible CPA submission in 2027 — Passed by roll call (full tally not captured) (1:28:18)
- “the first thing we do when a project comes in that's high is we say, can this be broken or can it be phased?” — Leslie Harrison (1:13:05)
- “It sounds like it's a lot like the town common.” — Diane Smith (1:12:24)
- “I just want to make sure that if we decide to push it off a year that we only push it off a year” — Leslie Harrison (1:28:10)
Trinity Church steeple grant wins support
Watch: 0:01:57–0:44:00
Peter Carlsen asked the commission to support the church's application for a $265,000 CPA grant to cover phase two of its steeple restoration. He said the 23 Main Street Greek Revival meeting house is believed to be the oldest non-residential building in town still used for its original purpose. It also hosts scout troops, recovery groups and other community gatherings.
In 2024, engineers found serious decay in the steeple's 178-year-old timber frame and recommended repairs within 18 to 24 months. In phase one, which the church paid for itself at about $301,000, crews took down the spire and bell on March 31, rebuilt the tower stairs and reinforced the sanctuary roof. Phase two, budgeted at $479,000 with $214,000 from Trinity, will replace or repair tower posts, rebuild the belfry deck, put the spire back, add copper roofing and paint the tower. The whole project is estimated at $780,576, and the church would cover about 66 percent of it.
Bob Licht asked whether the church could raise its share. He also asked what would happen if phase two stalled, noting that the Historical Society had removed its steeple entirely. Peter Carlsen said that was "not our intent whatsoever." He said construction is targeted for mid-2027. The bell will not go back up. Greg Nowak said that "the load for a swinging bell is substantially higher" than for a bell that is struck, and the church decided a stationary bell wasn't worth the cost.
Tom Reirden asked Greg Nowak about snow and wind loads, framing materials and the cause of the rot. Greg Nowak said the transfer beams were rotted so badly that a tool could be pushed in "all the way to the handle," apparently from water damage over time. Tom Reirden urged the church to make the work "as watertight as possible." He warned that PVC-type trim like Azek expands and contracts with temperature and needs careful detailing.
Tim Cashmore asked whether the church would need a preservation restriction like the one First Parish took on. Bob Licht said he didn't believe it would be required. He called the church "really the center of the historic area of Main Street" and the likely heart of a future historic district, though he said that district is several years away. The vote to support the grant was unanimous, after a muted member's yes was confirmed. Bob Licht will draft the letter for a formal vote in October.
- Motion: Submit a letter of support for Trinity Church's CPA application to the Community Preservation Committee — Passed unanimously (0:42:02)
- “this is something that the congregation is committed to getting done.” — Peter Carlsen (0:22:20)
- “There was substantial rot damage” — Greg Nowak (0:33:21)
- “if that is something that this commission would require, you know, in order to support our we would want to start pursuing that” — Tim Cashmore (0:39:32)
Other business
Minutes approved
Watch: 1:29:14–1:30:10
The agenda listed the June 17 minutes, but Bob Licht said the minutes up for approval were from August 19. They were approved without discussion.
- Motion: Accept the minutes of August 19 — Passed (1:29:58)
Howard Street National Register update
Watch: 1:30:10–1:31:20
Bob Licht said he is "at wit's end" with the Howard Street National Register nomination. $3,500 of the CPA money has been spent and $3,500 remains, but the consultant has not responded. The project stays open for now. If she doesn't follow up, he may move her files to a new contractor.
Planning Board historical issues
Watch: 1:31:20–1:31:58
There were no updates on the stone wall removal on the scenic road at 17 Green St. or the cell tower at 409 Green St. Both will come back next meeting.
Committee updates
Watch: 1:31:58–1:35:15
The CPC has not met yet, and the master plan implementation committee meets the next night, Leslie Harrison said. Bob Licht said the Revolution250 committee will march in the Applefest parade. The Revolutionary War monument for the town common is finished and is waiting on a crane, with a dedication to follow.
Tom Reirden said the new fire station is due to have a weathertight shell in early October. That was also the original completion date, but weather, soil removal and steel issues caused delays. He said the curved retaining wall, up to 32 feet tall, is "a lot better looking than I had imagined."
New business: MACRIS, White Cliffs, brochure
Watch: 1:35:15–1:38:59
The MACRIS expansion is likely tabled because the original consultants haven't sent a quote. Tom Reirden has sent language on interiors for the White Cliffs preservation restriction. Bob Licht proposed updating the commission's trifold brochure next year.
Bob Licht also reported a demolition request for 83 Southwest Cutoff. The building dates from 1976 and does not meet the bylaw's definition of a significant building, so the commission has no say.
No other CPA bids this year; adjournment
Watch: 1:38:59–1:40:41
Leslie Harrison asked whether the commission should apply for anything else this CPA cycle, such as a new sign. Bob Licht said he would rather take time to plan, aside from Trinity and possibly MACRIS. The next meeting is October 21, when the Trinity letter will come up for a vote. The meeting adjourned, with an absent member counted as abstaining.
- Motion: Adjourn — Passed, one member absent counted as abstaining (1:40:41)
Who spoke
- Bob Licht (likely), the chair — 22 min, 37 sec, 34% of speaking time, 275 turns
- Peter Carlsen (likely), a Trinity Church project team member — 14 min, 26 sec, 21% of speaking time, 136 turns
- Diane Smith (likely), the labyrinth designer — 14 min, 14 sec, 21% of speaking time, 150 turns
- Leslie Harrison (likely), a commission member — 7 min, 37 sec, 11% of speaking time, 84 turns
- Tom Reirden (likely), a commission member — 4 min, 24 sec, 7% of speaking time, 59 turns
- Greg Nowak (likely), the consulting structural engineer — 2 min, 57 sec, 4% of speaking time, 36 turns
- Tim Cashmore (likely), a Trinity Church representative — 57 sec, 1% of speaking time, 6 turns
- Unidentified speaker (S8) — 17 sec, 0% of speaking time, 7 turns
Possible Open Meeting Law issues
Potential issues to consider, not legal determinations. Complaint deadline: October 16, 2026.
Agenda
- Discussing a specific demolition request under the vague catch-all agenda heading 'Other Issues for the Commission.' Discussed at 1:37:00.
During the meeting
- 0:42:00 Recording a remote member's roll-call vote through lip-reading and a thumbs-up gesture after his audio failed repeatedly.
- 0:43:00 Historic District Commission may violate OML if the chair's stated plan to draft the Trinity Church letter and send it to members 'to gather their opinions' outside a posted meeting results in unlawful deliberation by email.
- 1:29:00 Notice requirements by approving minutes from August 19 when the posted notice specified minutes from a June 17 meeting.
See the Open Meeting Law page on Mass.gov for information on the Open Meeting Law.
Summary last updated Nov 14, 2026 at 12:32 PM.