Peaslee School Building Committee ·
Peaslee committee weighs how to hire a builder as town warns debt limit is close
Peaslee School Building Committee, September 15, 2026
Meeting summary · Northborough. Written from the meeting's automatically-generated transcripts; names come from voice recognition and may be incomplete. Names in italics are likely but not yet confirmed.
The Peaslee School Building Committee spent most of Tuesday's virtual meeting on how to hire a contractor for the new elementary school. The choice is between a traditional low-bid "design-bid-build" contract and a "construction manager at risk" brought in early, which consultants put at roughly $2.6 million more in early estimates. No vote was taken, and members are expected to decide on October 20. Earlier, Jason Little warned that borrowing about $70 million for the project would take the town to the limit of its own debt policy by 2031, leaving little room to borrow for anything else.
Builder hiring method: low bid or an early partner?
Watch: 0:05:23–0:39:10
The owner's project manager, PMA Consultants, set up the main discussion. Ian Sheridan said the committee should choose a delivery method by October so that estimates and the December 10 state submission reflect it (0:05:23). If the town picks a construction manager at risk (CM at risk), it also has to send the state a letter asking permission, which is another reason for the timeline (0:14:50).
Ian Sheridan described design-bid-build as simpler, with clear roles and a known price before construction, since the lowest bid wins and "there is no negotiation." The owner carries more risk, though: change orders and claims are more likely, schedules run longer, and the builder gives no input during design. A CM at risk joins during design, can release early work packages for site work or geothermal, and shares some of the risk. That approach can cost more, and it can be hard to tell whether the negotiated guaranteed maximum price is the best available.
Several members focused on cost. Sean asked whether the consultants had any incentive to push the price up. "There's no incentive for us to go up or down," replied Kent, who said fees are set against a state database (0:23:05). Sean said the town "has some pretty specific financial challenges, and I worry about it." Kelly Guennette asked for a ballpark difference. Kent said preliminary estimates showed about $2.6 million more for the CM route. A shorter schedule could "take a big bite out of it," for example 18 months of construction instead of 24 (0:32:23). Ian Sheridan added that a construction manager also charges some preconstruction fees.
Two members with industry experience gave mixed views. Rob said a partnership approach "helps derisk the project further," but he called it a risk too when the town is so cost-sensitive. He kept his own preference to himself (0:28:16). Tristan said all the schools he had built in Massachusetts were CM at risk, and he called the schedule advantage "a big help." He cautioned that early bidding means "you don't know what the final cost will be" until wheels are already in motion (0:30:15).
School officials said the town's earlier projects, including Lincoln Street, were built design-bid-build (0:38:01). The consultants suggested members talk with neighboring districts that have used construction managers. Erika Hall said the committee will take up the question again at its October 20 meeting.
- “at the end of the day it's the committee's decision on which procurement method” — Ian Sheridan (0:27:08)
- “you're able to probably get an eight-month jump start on bidding where you're you're only getting three weeks” — Kent (0:26:02)
- “So the question is given the economic and costs of you know steel and construction materials does one method protect the district or the town more” — Greg Martineau (0:34:18)
Finance director: Peaslee borrowing would hit town's debt ceiling
Watch: 0:48:57–1:00:19
Kelly Guennette said residents keep asking about money, and she invited Jason Little to share slides from the town's September 10 financial summit (0:48:57).
Jason Little said the town has reached its Proposition 2½ levy capacity. Requests in the capital plan exceed current resources by about $8 million. He has been modeling the project at $100 million gross and $70 million in borrowing after state reimbursement. Under the town's policy of keeping debt service below 10% of the annual budget, "we'd be at our 10% limit" in 2031, when the first principal payment comes due (0:53:20). The town is therefore holding off on borrowing for other capital items until the project's cost is known.
He repeatedly asked for better figures: "people keep telling me my number's too high... I hope it does go down. So, please somebody point me to that." Kent said the full project value has to be carried for local funding, and actual reimbursement figures should arrive in early February. Ian Sheridan said the state is reviewing eligible costs, with possible increases taking effect January 1, 2027.
At the request of Mike Tietjen, Jason Little walked through a five-year tax bill projection. It assumes 3% annual increases in the town and school budgets and shows bills rising further once Peaslee debt is added (0:58:37). The full presentation is posted on the town's budget webpage.
- “we shouldn't borrow for anything additional before we know the the the total costs. for this project” — Jason Little (0:57:10)
- “the town's reached its uh Proposition 2 and a half levy capacity” — Jason Little (0:49:28)
Other business
Outreach plans and Select Board questions
Watch: 0:47:22–1:05:38
The communication subcommittee will staff a table at the Applefest street fair on Saturday, Sept. 26, from 10 to 3. It plans to launch a Facebook page and a video that same week, and to set up at school open houses and the polls on election day. Members were reminded that the table must stay educational and not promote a vote. Sean Bevan said two high school students will run social media under a marketing teacher who is a Peaslee alum.
Mike Tietjen said the project is now a standing item on Select Board agendas. At the first update on September 14, board members questioned the building's condition ("my kid was there only 5 years ago") and whether the town should run a preschool (1:03:11). Greg Martineau answered that "we are legally obligated to offer preschool... It's a must-have" (1:04:37). The date of the next design subcommittee meeting, possibly October 15, is still to be confirmed.
Opening and minutes
Watch: 0:00:27–0:04:33
Erika Hall opened the meeting and thanked members, consultants and staff for work over the summer. The July 28 minutes were approved by roll call.
- Motion: Approve the July 28, 2026 meeting minutes — Passed by roll call (tally unclear) (0:03:09)
Project manager status report
Watch: 0:04:36–0:05:23
A PMA Consultants team member reported that the schematic design kickoff has been held, the project schedule has been updated, and PMA attended the state school building authority's board meeting in late August.
Designer update
Watch: 0:39:25–0:44:19
Kent outlined schematic design work. It includes reviewing the space template, floor plans and occupancy schedule, keeping building systems simple enough for current facilities staff to manage, and holding a kitchen equipment meeting on September 29. The designers will also consult town departments and look into energy incentives. Cost estimates are due in late October or early November, ahead of the December 10 submission to the state, after which "this is really no turning back."
Invoices approved
Watch: 0:44:19–0:47:22
Rob moved approval of the invoice packet, saying the invoices were accurate and "trending back onto our schedule of values." The packet includes the Applefest table fee. Sean asked whether the fee could be waived. Jason Little said Applefest is run by a separate committee and that other town boards pay the same fee.
- Motion: Approve the invoice package as submitted — Passed by roll call (0:44:54)
- “I tried to muscle them, but they're they're a tough group” — Mike Tietjen (0:46:14)
New business, public comment and adjournment
Watch: 1:05:38–1:07:57
Kent said the team is looking at a committee member's question about whether the building could be changed to reduce cost. No one from the public commented. The meeting adjourned at 8:11 p.m.
- Motion: Adjourn — Passed by roll call (1:06:51)
Who spoke
- Kent (likely), a Flansburg designer representative — 13 min, 36 sec, 27% of speaking time, 100 turns
- Ian Sheridan, Project Manager, Peaslee School Project — 9 min, 52 sec, 20% of speaking time, 64 turns
- Jason Little, Finance Director — 6 min, 42 sec, 14% of speaking time, 33 turns
- Erika Hall (likely), the chair — 6 min, 11 sec, 12% of speaking time, 54 turns
- Kelly Guennette, a committee member — 3 min, 43 sec, 7% of speaking time, 34 turns
- Tristan (likely), a committee member — 2 min, 24 sec, 5% of speaking time, 15 turns
- Sean (likely), a committee member — 1 min, 55 sec, 4% of speaking time, 31 turns
- Mike Tietjen, Select Board Vice Chair — 1 min, 49 sec, 4% of speaking time, 15 turns
- Rob (likely), a committee member — 1 min, 2 sec, 2% of speaking time, 12 turns
- Unidentified speaker (S10), a PMA Consultants team member — 41 sec, 1% of speaking time, 10 turns
- Sean Bevan, Algonquin Regional High School Principal — 37 sec, 1% of speaking time, 2 turns
- Greg Martineau, Superintendent of Schools — 33 sec, 1% of speaking time, 7 turns
- Unidentified speaker (S13) — 27 sec, 1% of speaking time, 4 turns
Possible Open Meeting Law issues
Potential issues to consider, not legal determinations. Complaint deadline: October 15, 2026.
Agenda
- Conducting a detailed town finance presentation on capital budget and tax projections under the generic 'Subcommittee Reports' agenda heading. Discussed at 0:48:00.
During the meeting
- 0:00:00 The chair's opening remarks gave remote-access instructions but did not announce that the meeting was being recorded.
See the Open Meeting Law page on Mass.gov for information on the Open Meeting Law.
Summary last updated Nov 14, 2026 at 5:39 PM.