Select Board ·
Board names new fire chief, presses on school preschool costs and a stormwater fee
Select Board, September 14, 2026
Meeting summary · Northborough. Written from the meeting's automatically-generated transcripts; names come from voice recognition and may be incomplete.
Agenda (town Agenda Center) Watch on YouTube
The Select Board unanimously moved ahead with Keith Darling, a Franklin veteran who is expected to start October 1. The longest debates were about money. Jonathan Rea questioned a roughly $10 million preschool piece of the Peasley School rebuild, which has a pre-reimbursement price of about $98 million and a planned net town cost of $70 million. He also said he was skeptical of a proposed stormwater utility fee, which Scott Charpentier called just "a tool in the toolbox." Members agreed not to rush that fee, a regional dispatch decision, or a downtown redevelopment at 4 West Main Street, where the developer agreed the night's meeting was "premature."
Peasley School rebuild: chair questions preschool cost and the town's share
Watch: 1:00:12–1:36:08
Mike Tietjen, who serves on the Peasley Building Committee, gave the update. The committee chose new construction behind the 1962 school, keeping the neighborhood-school model and adding pre-K. Students would stay in the old building during construction, which avoids an estimated $4 million to $5 million in modular classrooms that the state won't reimburse. Schematic design is due to the Massachusetts School Building Authority (MSBA) on December 10. The project would go to town meeting in April, with a school opening around fall 2030.
The cost conversation got pointed. Jonathan Rea said he remembered hearing early on about a town share of $40 million to $50 million and asked what to expect now (1:12:35). Mike Tietjen said the chosen option was "$98 million plus" before reimbursement. Jason Little explained that the 48.68% MSBA rate applies only to eligible costs, so the town's actual share will be larger. He said a preschool component accounts for about $10 million of the total. Ian Sheridan added that items such as auditoriums aren't reimbursable (1:15:27).
The preschool became the flashpoint. "Northboro is not in the business of preschool," Jonathan Rea argued (1:27:02), noting that the town has plenty of private preschools. He warned that the vote would come in a costly winter, with high fuel prices and rising property taxes. Mike Tietjen said he would "disagree on the premise." He explained that the district needs five pre-K classrooms but has room for only three, in space that wasn't designed for young children. The project would keep the current tuition-based model, not create free pre-K. Leslie Rutan confirmed that other locations had been checked and said residents need to hear that. Stephanie Bacon added that more parents now can't afford to stay home.
Jason Little said town debt planning has used a $70 million net figure from the start so that no one gets sticker shock. Karina Pena said the MSBA has signaled that it is looking for ways to help communities with rising costs, though it made no promises. Asked whether the scope is frozen, Mike Tietjen said: "Nothing's final until we go through schematic design." He asked for a standing Peasley update on board agendas and noted the committee will have a booth at Applefest.
- “if this thing becomes a thing where people start adding on a lot of stuff to it, I think it's going to be messy.” — Jonathan Rea (1:17:50)
- “we as a town would not be able to afford a project anywhere near this without MSBA reimbursement” — Mike Tietjen (1:11:16)
- “We've continued to use the 70 million estimate from pretty much from the beginning.” — Jason Little (1:33:17)
Stormwater utility pitched as a fairer funding source, met with skepticism
Watch: 1:37:58–2:37:09
Scott Charpentier and Emily Sherbo introduced a stormwater utility. It would be an enterprise fund, like water and sewer, paid through a fee based on each property's paved and roof area instead of through the tax levy. Federal stormwater permit rules are "only becoming more stringent," the consultant said. A preliminary study found unmet needs, mostly culvert and drain replacements, that could raise stormwater spending about 77%. A typical single-family home could be one billing unit of about 3,600 square feet. In nearby Hudson, that unit costs about $24.75 a quarter.
Stephanie Bacon said residents now pay roughly $200 a year for stormwater through taxes, an amount the fee could "plausibly" cut in half. The reason is that businesses with large paved areas would pay more. Mike Tietjen said the change could essentially flip the current 70/30 residential-commercial split.
Jonathan Rea called himself a skeptic "of like being in a hard tax year and finding a way to add another fee" (2:09:20). He said he found enterprise funds the least transparent part of town finances and that only a small share of Massachusetts towns use stormwater fees. He also questioned the startup and administrative costs and the idea of capping bills for large commercial properties. Scott Charpentier said he wasn't there to sell anything. He said current staff could likely handle the work, though there would be a "hump" of resident questions.
Members agreed not to rush. "No rush," Jeff Ostiguy said (2:23:48). He insisted the town have its communication plan ready before going to town meeting, which is April 27. Julianne Hirsh asked to hear more about the environmental benefits. A $60,000 consultant proposal for the next phase is waiting on Scott Charpentier's desk. He will send its scope and a rough timeline to the board and return at the next meeting. During public comment, Jacob Jones called the plan a "rain fee" and urged the board not to approve the $60,000.
- “It could plausibly be that residents will pay half of what they're paying.” — Stephanie Bacon (2:10:21)
- “It's just an option and and and a a tool in the toolbox” — Scott Charpentier (2:25:04)
- “If it can't be ready for us to bring something like this to town meeting, we should not under any circumstances bring it to town” — Jeff Ostiguy (2:35:06)
Budget guidance sparks tension over appropriations committee's role
Watch: 3:22:36–4:01:51
Members reviewed the September 10 financial summit. Jeff Ostiguy said its most important message was getting everyone in one room to hear "we're up against it here." Jonathan Rea then walked through guidance he had emailed for fiscal 2028 budgets. It would base budgets on a three-year average of actual spending instead of increases on prior appropriations, show budget-versus-actual variances, list encumbrances separately, tag items as need-to-have or nice-to-have, and keep a headcount roster.
Jason Little cautioned that year-end leftovers have run about $1 million-plus, roughly 1.3% of an $85 million to $90 million budget. Budgeting much tighter could worry bond rating agencies, he said, pointing to a $400,000 snow and ice overrun. He said the bigger drivers are health insurance, which is forecast to rise 12% (about $1 million), and staff raises of about half a million dollars. Stephanie Bacon said departments already go line by line and that there would be no new positions.
The tone sharpened when Jonathan Rea said that, having watched every appropriations meeting, he "did not see operating expense even talked about" (3:40:09). Leslie Rutan pushed back: "We're all volunteers, including them," and said she heard "a negative tone." She proposed inviting the appropriations and financial planning chairs in. Jonathan Rea said he meant no vilification and was "seeking to understand."
When Jonathan Rea asked again for views, Jeff Ostiguy said the board had already answered three times. Jonathan Rea apologized "if it seemed like it was not listening." Leslie Rutan also said she would rather discuss such ideas in open session than reply to emails. The board settled on inviting both committees in October.
- “So, I want to be very very careful that we don't vilify them.” — Leslie Rutan (3:42:05)
- “listen, onboard the answer and then move forward.” — Jeff Ostiguy (3:47:17)
- “we got to be sure that we're not being irresponsible with our with our assumptions of what what people can produce in a budget.” — Jason Little (3:36:39)
4 West Main Street: developer and board stuck on 'chicken and egg'
Watch: 0:01:03–0:55:48
The NRB Enterprises team returned with an update. Dean Temple said a cursory look found no obvious structural issues but did find water damage. He said the rubber roof membrane "gives way under foot." Nick Foley said the team is reconsidering whether second-floor offices or more apartments make sense above a first-floor restaurant and community center. He asked for a nonbinding memo on how much parking and zoning relief the town would allow.
Jeff Ostiguy called it "a chicken and egg conversation" (0:10:53). The board can't talk about parking, he said, without knowing the building's best use, and "a whole bunch of apartments" may not excite residents (0:33:52). Leslie Rutan saw a "catch 22" and said the developer deserves a starting number. Stephanie Bacon suggested that the team design around the roughly 40 spaces in the lot. Asked by Jonathan Rea whether the meeting came too early, the representative said it was "probably premature meeting. Absolutely."
Bob Frederico told the team to "figure out your tenants first." He said the building has mold and needs "a whole rebuild" of its systems, and he urged a performance bond so the town isn't left with "a huge white elephant." Under Jonathan Rea's questioning, the representative said a new trust of local "friends and family" would buy the building, with construction financing through Clinton Savings. The original proposal put about $200,000 in initial capital.
Next steps: sketches and a code study in about three or four weeks, and exploratory cuts into walls coordinated through Stephanie Bacon. The board told the team not to rush.
- “You don't want to have a huge white elephant here because something went ary during the construction process.” — Bob Frederico (0:28:21)
- “if we put good businesses in a building that can't support it.” — Jeff Ostiguy (0:15:33)
Other business
Opening and public comment
Watch: 0:00:06–0:01:03
Jonathan Rea opened the meeting at 6:30 p.m. with all five members present. The board recited the Pledge of Allegiance. No one spoke during the opening public comment.
Keith Darling appointed fire chief
Watch: 0:55:50–1:00:12
Jonathan Rea explained that the deputy chief, who had been the board's preferred candidate, withdrew to stay in his role. The town then turned to Keith Darling, the top-ranked candidate from the assessment process. Darling has 24 years with the Franklin Fire Department and 32 years in emergency medical services. He is an Army veteran and has deployed with a federal disaster medical team.
Jeff Ostiguy moved to approve the contract and appointment, pending a background check. Keith Darling called the job "an awesome responsibility" that "I don't take it lightly." The start date is expected to be October 1, and the appointment was met with applause.
- Motion: Approve the employment contract with Keith Darling as fire chief as presented and approve the appointment, both contingent on a satisfactory background investigation — Approved by roll call (tally not clear in captions) (0:58:06)
Highway garage gate hours set
Watch: 2:37:26–2:58:53
Residents had complained after the gate to the public works yard, where they drop off yard waste, failed to open on time one day. Jonathan Rea said the posted hours didn't match practice. Scott Charpentier said the gate has reduced illegal dumping, though the town was recently billed extra for construction debris.
Brian Griffin, whose officers handle off-hours opening, said: "I just need to know a time to tell my folks." Members agreed on new hours: Monday, Wednesday, Thursday and Friday, 8 a.m. to 4 p.m.; Tuesday, 8 a.m. to 7 p.m.; and Saturday and Sunday, 8 a.m. to 3 p.m. There will be no added overtime. Scott Charpentier will update the sign and announce the change in the town's news email. He warned that occasional misses will still happen.
- “we don't want to pay overtime for a gate.” — Jonathan Rea (2:56:39)
Dispatch and radio: no rush toward a regional center
Watch: 2:58:53–3:22:34
Stephanie Bacon compared staying with the town's own dispatch against joining the MetroWest regional emergency communications center. New radio work is needed either way, with $2.7 million estimated if the town stays on its own. A regional center's costs are still unknown, though the state could pay the town's share in full for three years. A $2 million federal earmark request is still waiting on Senate appropriations.
Leslie Rutan said she is moving further away from joining, noting Brian Griffin's view: "We don't have a service issue." Jonathan Rea said he is open to a regional center but called it "a multi-year conversation." He suggested setting up some structure, possibly with finance committee members, to review the data. Stephanie Bacon will gather cost quotes and grant options.
- “Safety is costly unfortunately.” — Stephanie Bacon (3:17:13)
Minutes
Watch: 4:01:54–4:03:10
The August 24 minutes were held for a later meeting because Julianne Hirsh hadn't had time to review them. The board voted on the August 10 minutes.
- Motion: Approve the August 10, 2026 meeting minutes as presented — Approved by roll call (tally and any abstention unclear) (4:02:50)
Reports: housing bills, new assessor, cell tower appeal clock
Watch: 4:03:10–4:27:31
Stephanie Bacon said state bills that would allow duplexes by right and loosen variance standards are still in a legislative conference committee. She recommended against any zoning changes until a final bill passes. Other updates: - New principal assessor Linda Barisha started September 9, so the tax classification discussion moved to September 28. - Construction on Blake and Pierce streets begins September 28. - The dam removal project received a $1 million grant. - Phase one of the Assabet drainage project is out to bid, and about $1.4 million more will be needed later.
Jon Cogswell asked how residents would learn whether the denied cell tower application at 409 Green Street had been appealed in federal court. Town counsel's opinion, which Stephanie Bacon read aloud, suggested the deadline rolls to Monday, September 14. The town may not be notified of a federal filing. Mike Tietjen pointed residents to the video of the 9/11 ceremony, and Leslie Rutan promoted the scholarship committee's $10,000 fundraising drive.
Public comment: Peasley debt and the 'rain fee'
Watch: 4:27:31–4:31:56
Jacob Jones praised the board and the summit presentation. He called the plan to make interest-only payments for the first two years of the Peasley bond "a big big red flag." He asked the board to model smaller net costs and to reject the $60,000 stormwater study.
Future agenda items and adjournment
Watch: 4:33:50–4:45:44
Coming up: - September 28: tax classification and a short explainer on enterprise and revolving funds. - September: Safe Routes to School, moved up from October. - October: appropriations and financial planning committees. - November: state legislators on housing, and election planning. - Later: a review of aged warrants, and an alternative voting location in December. - A standing Peasley update. Julianne Hirsh asked for follow-up on a state trail approval and on Route 20 flashing beacons that are now slated for 2028. The board skipped executive session as unnecessary and adjourned.
- Motion: Adjourn — Outcome unclear (captions end) (4:45:44)
Who spoke
- Stephanie Bacon, Town Administrator — 46 min, 4 sec, 20% of speaking time, 313 turns
- Jonathan Rea, Select Board Chair — 37 min, 39 sec, 16% of speaking time, 339 turns
- Scott Charpentier, Public Works Director — 24 min, 15 sec, 11% of speaking time, 161 turns
- Mike Tietjen, Select Board Vice Chair — 23 min, 45 sec, 10% of speaking time, 117 turns
- Emily Sherbo, Stormwater Consultant — 17 min, 3 sec, 7% of speaking time, 78 turns
- Nick Foley, NRB Trust — 15 min, 54 sec, 7% of speaking time, 99 turns
- Jason Little, Finance Director — 13 min, 32 sec, 6% of speaking time, 106 turns
- Jeff Ostiguy, Select Board Member — 9 min, 32 sec, 4% of speaking time, 86 turns
- Leslie Rutan, Select Board Member — 9 min, 13 sec, 4% of speaking time, 72 turns
- Bob Frederico, Building Commissioner — 7 min, 3% of speaking time, 79 turns
- Dean Temple, Architect, Haley Ward — 6 min, 38 sec, 3% of speaking time, 57 turns
- Julianne Hirsh, Select Board Member — 5 min, 44 sec, 3% of speaking time, 86 turns
- Jacob Jones, a Green Street resident — 3 min, 42 sec, 2% of speaking time, 14 turns
- Brian Griffin, Police Chief — 2 min, 48 sec, 1% of speaking time, 16 turns
- Karina Pena, OPM, Peasley School Project — 2 min, 33 sec, 1% of speaking time, 11 turns
- Ian Sheridan, Project Manager, Peaslee School Project — 1 min, 16 sec, 1% of speaking time, 3 turns
- Jon Cogswell, a Green Street resident — 1 min, 15 sec, 1% of speaking time, 3 turns
- Keith Darling, Fire Chief — 38 sec, 0% of speaking time, 3 turns
- Unidentified speaker (S19) — 33 sec, 0% of speaking time, 2 turns
Possible Open Meeting Law issues
Potential issues to consider, not legal determinations. Complaint deadline: October 14, 2026.
Agenda
- Using generic catch-all agenda headings ('Reports' and 'Any other business to come before the Board') that did not specifically identify the substantive matters discussed under them. Discussed at 3:49:00.
During the meeting
- 3:22:00 The chair emailed the full board a document setting out substantive budget-policy positions before the meeting, which could constitute deliberation among a quorum outside a posted session.
- 3:40:00 Discussing combining or restructuring the Appropriations and Financial Planning Committees under 'Reports,' a topic not separately listed on the agenda.
See the Open Meeting Law page on Mass.gov for information on the Open Meeting Law.
Summary last updated Nov 14, 2026 at 5:43 PM.