Select Board ·
Forecast shows $5 million in possible overrides as town leaders warn tax bills are unsustainable
Select Board, September 10, 2026
Meeting summary · Northborough. Written from the meeting's automatically-generated transcripts; names come from voice recognition and may be incomplete.
Northborough's first look at the fiscal 2028 budget came with a sobering forecast: even with department budgets held to 3% a year, the town faces budget gaps that would take roughly $5 million in Proposition 2½ overrides over five years, and average single-family tax bills rising about $1,200 a year. That doesn't count keeping eight grant-funded firefighters. Mike Sciacca warned that longtime residents on fixed incomes could be "pushed out," and Jonathan Rea called it "a need to have year, not a nice to have year." No numbers were approved; staff left with direction to build budgets from actual spending rather than last year's totals.
Five-year forecast: overrides, Peaslee debt and a $1,200-a-year tax climb
Watch: 0:42:38–0:56:43
The numbers that framed the night came from Jason Little's five-year forecast, and he called his own wrap-up "my uplifting conclusion" before walking the boards through it. The model assumes tight budgets: town departments and the K-8 schools grow 3% a year, the regional school assessments 5%, retirement 10%, and health insurance 12% in fiscal 2028, then 4% after that.
Even under those assumptions, the forecast shows a fiscal 2028 gap of about $1.85 million, presented as a Proposition 2½ override. Gaps over the five years add up to about $5 million. (0:49:39) A $1.85 million override would mean a 5.4% tax increase in fiscal 2028, according to Jason Little. (0:52:29) Over the past 10 years the average single-family bill rose about $380 a year. The projection is roughly $1,200 a year, driven largely by debt for the Peaslee School project. (0:54:22)
Several big costs are still unsettled. The forecast leaves out the eight SAFER grant firefighters. The grant runs nine months into fiscal 2028, so keeping them for the last three months would cost about $268,000, with a full year's cost in the years after. (0:51:20) Health insurance alone could rise about $1 million at 12%, though the town is pursuing plan design changes and won't have a firm renewal until January.
Debt is tight as well. Assuming $70 million in Peaslee borrowing, the town would reach its 10% local debt policy limit in the first year a principal payment comes due. (0:42:38) "We can't really fit any additional projects under the under the debt ceiling," Jason Little said. He listed the open questions: whether to keep the SAFER firefighters, whether to join a regional communications center or keep a stand-alone dispatch, and whether Peaslee moves forward. (0:55:43)
Later, John Rapa added that municipal bond rates are now "65-75 basis points higher" than when the fire station was financed, so a school bond's payments would be "a lot stiffer" than the town is used to. (1:31:48)
- “These models show Proposition 2 1/2 overrides amounting to about $5 million over over 5 years.” — Jason Little (0:55:08)
- “So we're all going to need to work together hard on on making these budgets come together.” — Jason Little (0:55:37)
- “health insurance is in red because we're we're we're continuing to work on it. We're hoping that number goes down” — Jason Little (0:51:20)
Leaders press for affordability and budgets built on actual spending
Watch: 1:15:39–1:31:48
Stephanie Bacon asked the boards whether departments should keep using fiscal 2027 dollars as the baseline and justify anything above it. (1:21:38) The answers turned into the night's main debate over affordability.
Mike Sciacca said comparing budgets to a 3% target misses the bigger picture. Even in the best case, he said, taxes rise about 23% over four or five years. "You can't have someone who purchased a house in Northborough 25 years ago who is now on a fixed income getting pushed out with a 35, 40,000 dollar tax bill," he said, warning that "that's where this is going." (1:23:36)
Jonathan Rea, speaking for himself rather than the board, had already set the tone: "It's a need to have year, not a nice to have year." (1:15:39) He said he is "not comfortable with just taking 3% of 27" because the fiscal 2027 budget often doesn't match what departments actually spent from 2023 to 2026. He told department heads to look at four years of actual spending, because "we're just building budgets on budgets, not budgets on actuals." He also suggested a checkbox on capital requests asking whether a project could use Community Preservation Act money instead. (1:24:48)
Leslie Rutan agreed it may be time to stop treating last year's number as the starting point, "dispensing with that as a baseline, so to speak." She added that she didn't want to take away from what departments need. (1:29:01)
Susan Sartori credited staff for starting earlier and discussing free cash sooner. She said the bigger job this year is public trust: "People are really upset about their tax bills." She urged the Select Board to "put together solid budget goals" so Stephanie Bacon has more guidance to give departments. (1:29:42) Board members did not vote on formal goals. Staff said they will keep working and reconvene once health insurance and school numbers firm up, likely in January.
- “it's not sustainable for budgets, even if they stay at 3%.” — Mike Sciacca (1:23:36)
- “Have the hard conversations cuz Jason put together a picture that we have a lot of hard work ahead of us.” — Jonathan Rea (1:15:39)
- “what we really need to do this year is build trust in the community with the process we put together.” — Susan Sartori (1:29:42)
Level funding vs. 3%: what departments say they would cut
Watch: 0:56:55–1:05:09
Before the meeting, Stephanie Bacon asked every department head to estimate what it would cost to keep current services, and what they would cut under level funding or a 3% cap. She stressed that "level funded 3% in level service are not necessarily the same thing." Contract raises, utilities and supplies can mean that flat dollars turn into real cuts. (0:05:59)
Most departments came in at or close to 3%. Recreation was at 2% and Health and Human Services at 2.8%. The Senior Center came in around 3%, but 72% of its budget is salaries and 25% is utilities, so level funding would mean fewer staff hours and shorter hours at the center. The library was at 3.58%, police at 4.71% and public works at 4.9%. Public works warned that cuts could hit paving and facility repairs, and that outsourcing federally mandated street sweeping could cost about $35,000 a year. (1:01:34)
Fire Rescue EMS came in highest, driven by the eight SAFER grant firefighters. Level funding would require about $312,000 in cuts, mostly in staffing. Stephanie Bacon called that "a structural funding decision for the town" rather than an ordinary departmental increase. (1:03:50)
She said staff will go through each budget line by line and drop money that hasn't been used. She also cautioned against budgeting so tightly that departments can't absorb surprises. Only a little over 1% of the town budget went unspent and flowed to free cash last year. (0:58:33)
- “there's not a lot of meat as we say every year but we will make sure of it” — Stephanie Bacon (1:03:50)
- “holding a department to the same same exact same dollars as fiscal year 27 could mean an actual reduction in services” — Stephanie Bacon (0:05:59)
Other business
Opening and framing
Watch: 0:01:06–0:08:11
Jonathan Rea opened the joint summit at 6:33 p.m. The Financial Planning Committee, chaired by Ken Picard, also had a quorum. The Appropriations Committee did not. The Pledge of Allegiance came a few minutes late, after Mike Sciacca raised a "real quick question." (0:04:40)
Stephanie Bacon said the night was not about approving numbers but about understanding the choices ahead. She listed the pressures: the end of the SAFER grant, school requests, health insurance, dispatch communications upgrades and the Peaslee School project.
FY2026 closeout and free cash
Watch: 0:08:23–0:42:38
Jason Little estimated that free cash, which is not yet certified, will be about $4.35 million. Revenues beat the budget by about $2.25 million (2.7%), helped by interest earned on fire station bond money that hasn't been spent yet. He cautioned that this income is unlikely to recur. About $1.16 million of budgeted spending went unspent. (0:21:55)
Policy caps free cash for the operating budget at $500,000, but last year the town used an extra $700,000 to avoid an override. If $1.2 million goes to operations again, about $3 million would be left for capital. The stabilization fund stood at $6.8 million. (0:34:42) Stephanie Bacon later cautioned that free cash is one-time money that has to be replaced the next year.
For fiscal 2027, values are expected to grow about 4.2% to roughly $4.9 billion. The average single-family tax increase is likely about $433 (4.1%), close to the $445 projected. (0:32:52) Capital requests total about $112 million for fiscal 2028, including about $100 million for Peaslee. After expected state reimbursement, Peaslee debt, enterprise funds and $3 million in free cash, about $8 million in capital needs has no funding source yet. That includes dispatch communications and a $2.5 million fire truck. (0:37:37)
New capital scoring system
Watch: 1:05:09–1:21:34
Ken Picard explained the committee's new scoring method for capital requests. Projects are rated 0 to 10 on weighted pillars: health and safety, urgency, financial alignment, supporting data, life-cycle cost and strategic alignment. "Everything is objective instead of subjective," he said. (1:09:04)
Bob Frederico urged weighing state and federal mandates, noting that his own training is legally required. Ken Picard said mandates are already part of the capital criteria. (1:10:51) Leslie Rutan praised the system as "very sophisticated." Stephanie Bacon said the boards appeared to agree to use it.
Next steps and adjournment
Watch: 1:32:17–1:33:48
Staff will meet with each department head and return with firmer numbers once health insurance rates (expected in January) and school figures come in. Both the Financial Planning Committee and the Select Board voted to adjourn, and the meeting ended at 8:04 p.m.
- Motion: Financial Planning Committee motion to adjourn — outcome unclear (1:33:16)
- Motion: Select Board motion to adjourn — Passed (1:33:16)
Who spoke
- Jason Little, Finance Director — 39 min, 30 sec, 54% of speaking time, 170 turns
- Stephanie Bacon, Town Administrator — 21 min, 12 sec, 29% of speaking time, 103 turns
- Ken Picard, the Financial Planning Committee chair — 3 min, 22 sec, 5% of speaking time, 40 turns
- Jonathan Rea, Select Board Chair — 3 min, 13 sec, 4% of speaking time, 20 turns
- Mike Sciacca, a Select Board member — 1 min, 45 sec, 2% of speaking time, 25 turns
- Susan Sartori, a Financial Planning Committee member — 1 min, 36 sec, 2% of speaking time, 14 turns
- Leslie Rutan, Select Board Member — 1 min, 1% of speaking time, 5 turns
- Bob Frederico, Building Commissioner — 51 sec, 1% of speaking time, 3 turns
- John Rapa, a meeting participant — 23 sec, 1% of speaking time, 3 turns
Possible Open Meeting Law issues
Potential issues to consider, not legal determinations. Complaint deadline: October 10, 2026.
Agenda
- Listing 'Direction, Consensus, and Next Steps' as a generic catch-all agenda item without identifying the specific decisions to be discussed. Discussed at 1:22:00.
See the Open Meeting Law page on Mass.gov for information on the Open Meeting Law.
Summary last updated Nov 14, 2026 at 5:36 PM.