Select Board ·
Select Board opens health insurance overhaul process over teacher and firefighter union objections
Select Board, August 10, 2026
Meeting summary · Northborough. Written from the meeting's automatically-generated transcripts; names come from voice recognition and may be incomplete.
Over objections from teacher and firefighter union leaders, the Select Board voted to adopt state health insurance law Chapter 32B, Sections 21-23. The law sets up a fixed, time-limited process for changing employee health plans. Stephanie Bacon said the vote changes no benefits yet but is needed to meet a July 1, 2027 deadline. Union leaders said they had little notice and asked for a delay. In the same long night, members heard about an early fiscal 2028 budget gap of about $1.85 million, wrestled with joining a regional 911 dispatch center, agreed to keep voting at the Senior Center through November, and moved one bidder's proposal for 4 West Main Street to the next round.
Board adopts health insurance law despite union pleas to wait
Watch: 2:37:19–3:22:30
The night's sharpest debate started before the board even went into executive session. Melissa Jameson asked the board to vote down Chapter 32B, Sections 21-23. She said the teachers' unions had agreed last spring to keep talking about cutting health costs, but "received a notice of an upcoming vote after there had been no action since May" (0:02:05). "Advocacy does not necessarily have to mean confrontation," she said (0:02:50). Jonathan Rea replied that the vote was "procedural" and that "we're not making decisions tonight" (0:03:51).
When the item came up, Stephanie Bacon told the board there were "no changes to healthcare, no changes to contribution." She said the law "just gives the town another tool" against one of its biggest budget pressures (2:37:26). Under it, each bargaining unit and the retirees would send one representative to a public employee committee. The two sides would then negotiate for 30 days. If they couldn't agree, a three-member review panel would step in (2:56:11). She said the town was aiming for changes by July 1, 2027, and "if we don't make a move, it's it's not going to be good" (2:44:36). Finance officials pointed to recent premium increases of 17% and 16%, and to a first quote of about 25% that was later brought down (2:42:55).
At Mike Tietjen's request, the board voted to take public comment on the item right away (2:48:54). Pat McManus said the town's existing insurance advisory committee had made plan changes this way before, in 2007. "Have we been doing it wrong this whole time?" he asked (2:55:29). He said he got the town's email on Wednesday and a certified letter on Saturday, ahead of a Monday vote. He said "we stand with the teachers" and asked the board to postpone (2:59:04). a retired town employee worried that retirees would get only a 10% weighted vote on the new committee and asked the board to table the item, saying "I just think it's being rushed" (3:15:19).
Greg Martineau called in to back adoption. He said all three partners in the joint health insurance purchasing group, Northborough, Southborough and the regional school district, must agree on plan design, which is hard to do across so many contracts. The law "does not take away" members' right to negotiate, he said (3:01:52).
Melissa Jameson came back to the microphone. She said a February plan pitch by the town's insurance advisor had "bamboozled" the unions, and "we feel very strongly that the town is not working in good faith with us" (3:05:33). Some aides make $21 an hour and could not cover a deductible, she said (3:06:18). Stephanie Bacon said the smaller committee would let the town actually get something done: "Have you heard the expression too many cooks spoil the broth?" (3:08:40). She said the rush came from an attorney's advice about the law's timeline: "Clock starts now" (3:16:18).
Board members called it a hard vote. Mike Tietjen said he grew up with two union parents, "lo and behold, I'm sitting here as part of management," but pointed to the town's "fiscal realities" (3:17:44). Julianne Hirsh called the costs "exorbitant" (3:20:43). Leslie Rutan moved adoption, and the motion passed on a roll call (3:21:15).
- Motion: Take public comment on agenda item 7 — Passed (roll call; tally not captured) (2:48:54)
- Motion: Accept M.G.L. Chapter 32B, Sections 21-23 and authorize Stephanie Bacon to carry out the required steps, including savings analyses, notice to the insurance advisory and public employee committees, and negotiations — Passed (roll call; tally not captured) (3:21:15)
- “So tonight, I'm asking you to choose collaboration over a rush decision.” — Melissa Jameson (0:02:50)
- “it's a tough vote. It's not easy.” — Mike Tietjen (3:18:30)
- “I do believe it should have been adopted a long time ago” — Greg Martineau (3:03:01)
Early FY28 budget shows a gap of about $1.85 million
Watch: 3:48:42–4:47:31
Jason Little presented an early fiscal 2028 model. He stressed that it was a starting point, not a conclusion. If every operating budget rose 3%, town departments would need $512,000 more and the K-8 schools $962,000. Health insurance is modeled at a 12% increase, about $1 million, and roughly 70% of that is tied to school employees (4:32:40). The retirement assessment is expected to rise about 10%. The model shows a shortfall, and an override, of $1.85 million (4:25:30).
The model leaves out costs that could make things worse. The fire department's SAFER grant runs out nine months into fiscal 2028, and covering the last three months would cost about $300,000. It also includes no new police staff (4:32:40). Jason Little said departments "sharpen their pencils" last year, when the town budget grew just $83,000. He was unsure "can we do it again for another 3% this year" (4:29:25). He framed the key question as "do we want to avoid an override?" (4:00:24). On the plus side, new growth should reach the projected $30 million in value, about $445,000 in tax revenue, and stabilization reserves stand at $6.8 million.
Jonathan Rea sounded relieved compared with last year: "This isn't as dire as last year" (4:09:16). He also urged closer line-by-line review of spending. Stephanie Bacon asked the board to agree to a 3% level-service target to start. She warned that a level-funded budget would mean cuts to personnel (4:39:12).
One new idea, a stormwater enterprise fund, drew pushback. It would move about $500,000 in stormwater costs off the tax rate and onto a separate fee based on each property's paved and roofed area (4:40:07). Jonathan Rea asked what it would cost to run and said such ideas are "kind of like a shell game sometimes. Not always" (4:46:06). Stephanie Bacon said the fee would charge owners for the hard surfaces they actually have. The topic will come back, and the tax classification discussion is set for September.
- “we're just putting we've got PTSD and keep putting 12 in because it keeps coming” — Jonathan Rea (4:15:06)
- “If we don't have to go that way, then why start out that way?” — Stephanie Bacon (4:39:12)
Regional 911 dispatch weighed against a $3 million radio overhaul
Watch: 1:52:28–2:24:38
Stephanie Bacon said a consultant's study found the town's emergency communications equipment needs nearly $3 million in upgrades. One option is to join the regional emergency communication center being formed by Westborough, Grafton and Southborough. It would be based in Westborough, run as an independent district, and split costs evenly between population and 911 call volume. The center has $15 million in state grants and aims to open in January 2028. She said Northborough would likely need to decide by about November (1:53:26). She passed on the regional directors' own advice: "don't do it just because of cost" (1:59:19).
Brian Griffin said he was keeping an open mind but had reservations. His biggest concern is the lobby going unstaffed: "as long as I'm chief, I won't close the door and that station's not going dark" (2:00:38). He compared outsourced dispatch to "calling 1-800 number," worried about dispatchers who have served for 15 years, and noted the town had turned down regional dispatch twice before (2:09:28).
Board members wanted harder numbers. Leslie Rutan said the board must look at everything to cut costs, but "I would have to know that there's an absolute benefit" over the current service (2:16:50). Julianne Hirsh asked why the state is pushing regionalization. Brian Griffin said about 55% of communities are now in regional systems (2:13:20). Members asked for the consultant and the center's director to come to a future meeting, and talked about a site visit.
- “we got to keep an open mind” — Brian Griffin (1:59:53)
- “we're talking about people, we're talking about positions, we're talking about major change” — Stephanie Bacon (1:58:09)
Senior Center stays the polling place through November
Watch: 1:31:00–1:52:28
Daymian Bartek said the spring election at the Senior Center was not efficient. Keeping precincts separate was hard, and the parking lot was full almost all day. "It was just chaos," she said (1:32:26). Brian Griffin said it "worked um barely" for a local election, but the single entrance is a bottleneck that worries him for the November governor's race (1:32:42). Leslie Rutan raised emergency vehicle access (1:47:19).
Julianne Hirsh asked about other sites, such as churches. Mitch Cohen urged the board to push mail-in voting. He said the school committee should be consulted before any move back to the schools: "It's their building" (1:49:37).
Daymian Bartek recommended staying put for the September 1 primary and November 3 election. The earliest change would be next spring's local election, and she said the decision should come four to six months ahead. Police, fire and public works will plan overflow parking and possibly shuttle election staff (1:44:32). Moving the polling place is a Select Board vote.
- “we can't make them do” — Daymian Bartek (1:38:33)
Other business
Opening public comment and executive session
Watch: 0:00:00–1:28:56
Jonathan Rea took public comment first, out of respect for the large crowd. The comments are covered under item 7. The board then voted by roll call to go into executive session on firefighter bargaining, the fire chief's contract and 4 West Main Street, and returned around 8 p.m. for the pledge.
- Motion: Enter executive session — Passed (roll call) (0:09:00)
State primary warrant
Watch: 1:29:14–1:31:00
Daymian Bartek said the state-mandated warrant had no changes. It will be posted in five places around town.
- Motion: Approve and sign the state primary warrant — Outcome unclear (roll call) (1:30:32)
MassDOT crosswalk beacons
Watch: 2:25:09–2:37:19
Scott Charpentier said MassDOT is designing flashing beacons for West Main Street at Pine Haven and at St. Rose of Lima, and for two Main Street crossings, one in front of Town Hall. Bidding is targeted for January 2028. The town already has 25 of these beacons. He said the town has already used every crosswalk that meets the grant rules (30 mph, under 5,000 vehicles a day).
4 West Main Street: NRB proposal advances
Watch: 3:22:34–3:31:00
Members said NRB's bid looked more realistic and better prepared on costs than the competing proposal, but stressed it was "not at the finish line." Jonathan Rea wants updated cost estimates and contingency plans. The vote asks NRB to return with its full team and engineering data, and it does not approve a sale.
- Motion: Advance NRB's proposal to the next phase of evaluation and due diligence; no sale or agreement authorized — Passed (roll call) (3:30:19)
- “There's a lot of half finishedish buildings in 20 where people thought they had it all figured out” — Jonathan Rea (3:29:36)
Street name for 17 Green Street
Watch: 3:31:00–3:46:28
Greg Martineau, speaking for himself, said "Knox Trail" alone could make people think there is a hiking trail at the end of the three-lot cul-de-sac. The board chose "Knox Trail Lane." Leslie Rutan said she preferred "Drive" but voted yes.
- Motion: Approve street name Knox Trail Lane for the 17 Green Street subdivision — Passed (3:45:38)
Zeh School roof funding agreement
Watch: 3:46:31–3:48:42
The board authorized Jonathan Rea to sign the standard MSBA agreement for the Zeh roof replacement, with an estimated maximum reimbursement of about $2.6 million.
- Motion: Authorize Jonathan Rea to execute the MSBA project funding agreement for the Marion E. Zeh roof — Passed (roll call) (3:48:10)
Economic development survey
Watch: 4:47:46–4:58:42
Stephanie Bacon reviewed a draft business survey. It asks owners how they would like to work with the town, whether through roundtables, an advisory group or a formal committee. a Select Board member said any committee needs the zoning and planning boards on board, or it will be "good going after bad." Julianne Hirsh asked how true the town's anti-business reputation is and suggested also surveying residents.
Reports, minutes and adjournment
Watch: 4:58:42–5:17:44
Stephanie Bacon's report covered a possible electronic sign to replace the Lions Club sign near Blake Street (about $60,000), the town's electricity rate ($13.96 versus National Grid's $17.18), and a departing assessor. Julianne Hirsh pressed for a lead on a Safe Routes to School grant for a Maple Street sidewalk. The application opens in October, and an update was promised. The June 22 minutes were approved, and the tax classification discussion was added for September.
Who spoke
- Stephanie Bacon, Town Administrator — 53 min, 1 sec, 29% of speaking time, 401 turns
- Jason Little, Finance Director — 37 min, 11 sec, 21% of speaking time, 223 turns
- Jonathan Rea, Select Board Chair — 22 min, 41 sec, 13% of speaking time, 221 turns
- Brian Griffin, Police Chief — 13 min, 45 sec, 8% of speaking time, 76 turns
- Mike Tietjen, Select Board Vice Chair — 7 min, 45 sec, 4% of speaking time, 68 turns
- Scott Charpentier, Public Works Director — 7 min, 24 sec, 4% of speaking time, 41 turns
- Leslie Rutan, Select Board Member — 7 min, 13 sec, 4% of speaking time, 65 turns
- Carter Brannon — 7 min, 8 sec, 4% of speaking time, 34 turns
- Daymian Bartek, Town Clerk — 6 min, 38 sec, 4% of speaking time, 28 turns
- Melissa Jameson, Northborough Teachers Association vice president — 5 min, 53 sec, 3% of speaking time, 26 turns
- Julianne Hirsh, Select Board Member — 4 min, 55 sec, 3% of speaking time, 65 turns
- Mitch Cohen, a 12 Whitney Street resident and former board member — 3 min, 17 sec, 2% of speaking time, 15 turns
- Pat McManus, the firefighters union president — 2 min, 12 sec, 1% of speaking time, 9 turns
- Greg Martineau, Superintendent of Schools — 2 min, 1 sec, 1% of speaking time, 8 turns
Possible Open Meeting Law issues
Potential issues to consider, not legal determinations. Complaint deadline: September 9, 2026.
Agenda
- Using generic agenda headings like 'Reports' and 'Any other business' to cover substantive, distinct topics such as a preservation restriction MOA and a sign replacement project. Discussed at 4:59:00.
During the meeting
- 0:00:00 The chair's opening remarks described only YouTube livestream logistics and never expressly stated that the meeting was being recorded, as required at the start of the meeting.
- 0:09:00 Giving a single blanket detrimental-effect declaration referencing only 'negotiating position' before entering executive session for Purpose 3 (collective bargaining/litigation strategy), Purpose 2, and Purpose 6 items, without the distinct 'bargaining or litigating position' language required for Purpose 3.
See the Open Meeting Law page on Mass.gov for information on the Open Meeting Law.
Summary last updated Nov 14, 2026 at 6:16 PM.