Planning Board ·
Planning board rejects Green Street cell tower under town bylaw, then approves it under federal law
Planning Board, August 10, 2026
Meeting summary · Northborough. Written from the meeting's automatically-generated transcripts; names come from voice recognition and may be incomplete. Names in italics are likely but not yet confirmed.
Agenda (town Agenda Center) Watch on YouTube
After almost six hours, the Northborough Planning Board voted just before midnight to approve TowerCo and Verizon's 130-foot monopole at 409 Green Street. A majority first turned down the tower's height under the town's own bylaw, which allows 75 feet in the residential district, and then approved it 3-1 under the federal Telecommunications Act. Members said they didn't think the town could win in court. Neighbors filled public comment with objections about the scenic roads, property values and how hard the company had looked for other sites. Millie Milton cast the lone vote against the federal approval, saying she was never shown proof that the alternatives had really been checked.
Board says no under the bylaw, yes under federal law
Watch: 1:58:40–5:42:38
Before deliberations began, Amy Poretsky explained the framework. If the board approves under the local bylaw, the application passes. If it denies locally, members then have to weigh the federal criteria, and a federal approval still lets the tower go up. Robin Stein warned that if the applicant shows a need for service and has nowhere else to go, a denial "is going to be the reason they can't provide them" and would be "very difficult" to defend (2:02:53).
Amy Poretsky said she was torn. Under the bylaw, she said, "I would deny it at the 75 ft locally" (2:14:49) because the road is rural and scenic. But she said the coverage maps showed a substantial gap, and that the town "can't just stop at town line." Anthony said the tower doesn't meet the bylaw, "but I don't think we have much of a choice from the Federal Communications Act," and added that the town doesn't have "a big appetite for lengthy lawsuits" given its budgets (2:19:55).
Bill Pierce argued the other way, pointing to the dog park the town approved knowing neighbors from other towns would use it: "We got to help each other" (2:16:53). Amy Poretsky answered that Boylston "did say no, which is why they're here" (2:20:53). Later Bill Pierce said he was the only member who would vote yes even under the local bylaw, citing his own dead zone at home and residents who couldn't call out during a storm on the first night of hearings (4:44:30).
Millie Milton focused on the scenic-road designation, calling the 135-foot structure "a rather bold contrast" with the fields where two scenic roads meet (2:18:35). Under the federal test she accepted that there was a gap but not that feasible alternatives had been ruled out. The town's peer reviewer said a board can't deny because another site "might" exist: "You need to deny because there is another alternative" (4:55:49). Millie Milton replied that only the tower company could vet other properties and that, in her view, it hadn't.
Near 11:30 p.m., Carrie said she did have some of the emails Millie Milton had asked for. Millie Milton said reviewing them now, "at 11:30 at night, 5 and a half hours into the meeting," didn't seem workable (5:16:22). Amy Poretsky floated continuing the hearing to Thursday, but Carrie said, "We're ready. We don't want any more continuations" (5:18:38). Robin Stein noted that the state's deadline for a decision runs out that Friday.
Under the local bylaw, the board voted down site plan approval, the height waiver and the special permit, and unanimously approved the two setback waivers. Those setbacks are to the property owner's own lot line and house, which members accepted because the owner agreed. Then, acting under the federal Telecommunications Act, the board approved the special permit, height waiver and site plan 3-1 (5:42:38). Millie Milton said she was "just not convinced" there was proof that other sites were really investigated (5:43:00).
- Motion: Under the town zoning bylaw only, grant site plan approval for a 110-foot monopole with a 5-foot lightning rod at 409 Green Street, subject to conditions — Failed 1-3 (5:33:12)
- Motion: Under the town zoning bylaw only, grant the setback waivers — Passed 4-0 (5:35:28)
- Motion: Under the town zoning bylaw only, grant the height waiver — Failed (exact tally unclear in captions) (5:36:46)
- Motion: Under the town zoning bylaw only, grant the special permit — Failed (exact tally unclear in captions) (5:38:19)
- Motion: Under the federal Telecommunications Act, grant the special permit, height waiver and site plan approval for a 110-foot monopole with a 5-foot lightning rod (built to 130 feet plus rod under the Spectrum Act), subject to conditions — Passed 3-1 (5:42:38)
- “the only thing for me that could ever trump that is safety” — Bill Pierce (4:45:15)
- “I do not feel that the applicant has done the most thorough job of basically looking at options” — Millie Milton (5:08:20)
- “if there aren't real alternative places to put this and you deny it, it's going to be very hard to defend.” — Robin Stein (4:55:38)
Neighbors press scenic, property-value and coverage objections
Watch: 0:42:59–1:57:55
Susan Sartori opened public comment by noting that 10 households had sent a 31-page memorandum citing federal court cases. Those cases, she said, upheld denials based on aesthetics. She has lived on 8.9 acres since 1990, with a house set to overlook the fields, and said the tower would be "looming in that open field." She estimated her home could lose 15% of its value and warned that tax abatements could cost the town more "than you will in a $10 to $20,000 potential legal suit" (0:49:24). When she said residents' photos had been refused, Laurie Connors said every photo was shared and is listed in the exhibits (0:45:27).
Sharon Barubi argued that the gap hadn't been proven. She said Verizon's own coverage map shows no gap, only two of 10 frequencies were modeled, and no drive-test data was provided. She urged the board to show "a backbone for believing in what our town is trying to stand up for" (0:57:28). Jon Cogswell called the area an economic engine for recreation and compared the tower to "billboards along the highways in Vermont" (1:09:48).
The town's peer reviewer answered several of the claims. Modeling the 700 and 2100 MHz bands is typical, he said, and a more negative signal number means weaker coverage, not stronger. At 12 feet a story, a 130-foot tower is "somewhere in the order of 11 stories, not 30" (1:00:45). Asked by Larry Blanchard about drive tests, he said the town code doesn't require them and that calling them more accurate than propagation models "is an incorrect" statement (1:06:17).
The town's peer reviewer also agreed with Jon Cogswell on one point. Northborough's documented public safety radio problems are near the Shrewsbury line, he said, and this tower "would not" resolve them (1:11:11).
Barbara Hopkins said the building inspector had told her that afternoon that the two existing poles at 351 Ball Street are not yet cleared for use. If they are running, she said, that is an active violation: "how do we believe that this applicant will then behave as told" (1:23:46). She asked the board to act "as an advocate for us the residents of North Borro" rather than for Boylston or Verizon (1:32:40).
- “What you're allowing them to propose is close to a 30story building.” — Susan Sartori (0:48:03)
- “A larger negative number is weaker coverage.” — the town's peer reviewer (1:00:00)
- “it's a true economic engine for Northboro” — Jon Cogswell (1:09:03)
How hard did the applicant look for other sites?
Watch: 0:01:09–0:14:43
The hearing reopened on a question left over from two weeks earlier. Millie Milton had asked for specific dates and correspondence showing when the applicant contacted the alternative sites: Davidian Farm, Tougas, the Haven and Boylston. She said the new submission "didn't really address my specific questions" and contained no emails, adding, "I'm having a little trouble with that" (0:02:43).
Ellen Fryman, sitting in for attorney Michael Fenton, said staff had searched files covering years of work by different people and turned over everything they found. "We're not providing anything that isn't true and correct," she said (0:04:44). She cited contacts in 2023 and said she had never been asked for this kind of record before.
Millie Milton then asked for the lease date to check the order of events. Laurie Connors said she had asked attorney Fenton for the lease and was told it was confidential (0:11:56). Brett found the memorandum of lease, which showed the lease was dated February 13, 2025 and the memorandum finalized in January 2026 (0:13:32). Millie Milton said that timing fit, but she still lacked proof of the outreach to other properties. The issue came back at the end of the night and shaped her vote.
- “I was very very specific in asking for what dates did they actually reach out to these people” — Millie Milton (0:02:43)
- “I specifically asked Mike Fenton for a copy of the lease and I was told that that was confidential” — Laurie Connors (0:11:56)
Will the conditions have teeth?
Watch: 1:14:48–1:54:15
Amy Poretsky wanted assurance that the two existing poles at 351 Ball Street would really come down. Carrie confirmed that if the applicant can't meet those conditions, the new tower won't go up (1:16:06). Robin Stein read the two-step conditions. Before getting a building permit, the applicant must show written authority to move Boylston's public safety equipment and Davidian Farm's equipment. Within 90 days of completion, it must move the equipment and remove both poles at no charge (1:17:27). Asked about adding a bond, she said she thought it already "has all the teeth it can have" (1:20:58).
Susan Sartori wasn't reassured: "you better have a lot of teeth in there, maybe some braces, too" (1:26:14). She said conditions on the 351 Ball Street project had not been followed, and she asked whether two poles within a mile would break the rules. The town's peer reviewer said the one-mile limit is a town bylaw, not state law. He said the overlap is a temporary arrangement so Boylston doesn't lose public safety coverage while equipment is moved.
Residents also asked whether the company could later add 20 feet under the federal Spectrum Act. Ellen Fryman explained that the board would approve 110 feet and the applicant would use its 20-foot Spectrum Act extension right away, reaching 130 feet: "we're in essence already exercising our rights under the Spectrum Act tonight" (1:47:37). Bill Pierce summed it up: "They can't do it twice" (1:38:41).
Millie Milton called it "an odd presentation." During deliberations, Barbara Hopkins raised a point of order. With public comment closed, she asked, "Why is the applicant allowed to provide information and influence the vote?" (3:54:13). Amy Poretsky said the hearing had been left open so the board could ask questions, not to take new input.
- “We're eliminating that right here tonight.” — Ellen Fryman (3:53:49)
- “I just want to make sure that it has teeth that it will actually be done.” — Amy Poretsky (1:20:52)
Other business
Opening of the continued hearing
Watch: 0:00:20–0:01:09
Amy Poretsky opened the continued hearing on TowerCo VI and Verizon's application for a 130-foot monopole inside a 70-by-70-foot fenced compound at 409 Green Street. The applicant had extended the decision deadline to this meeting.
Board questions on height, siting and colocation
Watch: 0:16:42–0:42:59
Carrie said the height grew from 120 feet to 130 feet because Verizon shifted its search area (0:18:19). Millie Milton asked whether the tower could be tucked behind a stand of trees to hide it from Ball Street. Laurie Connors said that would open the view from Green Street and bring it closer to neighbors to the north. The applicant said the spot was chosen for elevation, access and the farm owner's preference.
The applicant agreed to consider planting pine trees near the tower. The town's peer reviewer said putting two carriers at the same height on a monopole is "darn close to impossible" (0:39:46).
Bylaw walk-through: safety, removal bond, color, fence and lighting
Watch: 2:03:55–3:19:48
The town's peer reviewer said the radio-frequency exposure study complies with FCC standards and comes in "significantly below" them (2:06:53). He also called the applicant's $40,000 removal bond sufficient.
Members settled on the standard non-reflective galvanized finish rather than brown, after the town's peer reviewer said most new monopoles use that finish. The fence will be cedar. Lighting will be motion-sensored and aimed down inside the compound.
Ellen Fryman asked that spacing for the street trees be left open, since the landscape plan needs board approval before a building permit is issued.
Final conditions
Watch: 3:55:23–4:35:43
Laurie Connors read the draft conditions and the board revised them.
Street trees must be at least 2.5-inch caliber, with spacing and species set by the board; pine screening near the tower will also be discussed. Generator tests are limited to 9 a.m. to 5 p.m. on weekdays, up to 60 minutes a week. Non-emergency noise is capped at 10 dB above ambient. Broken or deteriorated fencing must be replaced within 90 days.
The space reserved for Northborough public safety equipment applies only while the pole stands and has at least one tenant. The height condition reads 110 feet plus a 5-foot lightning rod, extendable at construction to 130 feet plus the rod, for 135 feet total, under the Spectrum Act.
Decision write-up, hearing closed, adjournment
Watch: 5:43:46–5:51:47
The board adopted the consistent parts of the draft findings. It authorized Millie Milton and/or Amy Poretsky to work with Laurie Connors and town counsel to file the decision by the August 14 deadline. The dissent's reasons will be noted.
The board then closed the hearing and adjourned without taking up the agenda's minutes or other business.
- Motion: Adopt draft findings consistent with tonight's votes and authorize a board member to finalize and file the decision — Passed (tally unclear in captions) (5:50:46)
- Motion: Close the public hearing — Passed 4-0 (5:51:20)
- Motion: Adjourn — Passed 4-0 (5:51:48)
Who spoke
- Amy Poretsky, the chair — 1 hr, 3 min, 26% of speaking time, 809 turns
- Millie Milton (likely), a board member — 38 min, 33 sec, 16% of speaking time, 319 turns
- Unidentified speaker (S3), the town's peer reviewer — 34 min, 58 sec, 15% of speaking time, 134 turns
- Robin Stein (likely), the town counsel — 28 min, 30 sec, 12% of speaking time, 313 turns
- Laurie Connors, Planning Director — 22 min, 36 sec, 9% of speaking time, 209 turns
- Ellen Fryman (likely), an attorney for the applicant — 13 min, 14 sec, 6% of speaking time, 151 turns
- Susan Sartori, a Green Street resident — 9 min, 30 sec, 4% of speaking time, 58 turns
- Bill Pierce, a board member — 6 min, 29 sec, 3% of speaking time, 88 turns
- Sharon Barubi (likely), a Green Street resident — 5 min, 53 sec, 2% of speaking time, 49 turns
- Barbara Hopkins (likely), a Green Street resident — 5 min, 31 sec, 2% of speaking time, 28 turns
- Carrie (likely), a member of the applicant's team — 5 min, 7 sec, 2% of speaking time, 56 turns
- Jon Cogswell, a Green Street resident — 2 min, 23 sec, 1% of speaking time, 8 turns
- Larry Blanchard (likely), a Green Street resident — 1 min, 39 sec, 1% of speaking time, 12 turns
- Anthony (likely), a board member — 1 min, 13 sec, 1% of speaking time, 17 turns
- Brett (likely), a member of the applicant's team — 42 sec, 0% of speaking time, 9 turns
Possible Open Meeting Law issues
Potential issues to consider, not legal determinations. Complaint deadline: September 9, 2026.
During the meeting
- 0:00:00 Opening the August 10, 2026 meeting without the chair announcing that the meeting was being recorded.
- 0:00:00 Failing to formally announce, at the start of this remote meeting, the names of all members participating remotely.
See the Open Meeting Law page on Mass.gov for information on the Open Meeting Law.
Summary last updated Nov 14, 2026 at 6:14 PM.