Northborough Government News

Unofficial News from Northborough's Government Meetings

Design Review Committee ·

Design panel balks at all-metal look for HitTrax building near homes on Lyman Street

Design Review Committee, August 6, 2026

Meeting summary · Northborough. Written from the meeting's automatically-generated transcripts; names come from voice recognition and may be incomplete. Names in italics are likely but not yet confirmed.

Northborough's Design Review Committee would not sign off on a new owner's plan to swap the block-and-metal exterior at 1 Lyman Street for all-metal panels in new colors. Members said that design came out of a long, packed approval process with nearby neighbors. They told the builder to come back September 3 with side-by-side comparisons of the old and new designs, and the building inspector said the change likely needs Planning Board review as well. The committee also heard early plans for a Celebree preschool at 300 West Main Street and pressed for answers on parking and safety. It approved two business signs and voted on the look and mounting height of the town's new municipal signs.

HitTrax builder asked to bring back the approved 1 Lyman Street design

Watch: 0:00:42–0:43:05

The building at 1 Lyman Street was designed and permitted in 2021 for Cable Matters. After an appeal that took years to settle, that company sold the land. Patrick McCarty told the committee the buyer, HitTrax, makes baseball simulators in Northborough and needed room to grow. The building's footprint has shrunk from 20,232 to 16,632 square feet, he said, with no change to height, site layout or landscaping. What the owner wants to change is the outside: insulated metal panels in red and "imperial white" in place of the approved mix of concrete block and vertical metal (0:04:55).

Amy Poretsky, who also sits on the Planning Board, objected right away. She said six months went into the design and the Planning Board decision names it as the agreed plan. "It's kind of like what was the point of design review and the planning board if all of a sudden we're going to come in and change it," she said (0:07:24). A committee member remembered how hard the neighbors fought the project: "This one took so many meetings it was insane," he said, adding, "I'm not sticking my neck out for that" (0:09:23).

Patrick McCarty said his side never saw the design review minutes until "Thursday last week" because the renderings showed only gray and tan (0:08:04). He said a new buyer "expanding his business here in town" has the right to propose changes (0:10:04). He also argued that the trees would hide the difference: "From 100 ft away, I don't think you're going to see that difference" (0:13:00). He said the insulated panels make a better building envelope than block and admitted "there's obviously a cost implication" (0:24:50).

A committee member said she didn't mind the colors. But she said the new drawings looked flatter and more industrial than she remembered, and she recalled that the old design had pilasters that stuck out from the wall (0:20:44). She said past projects that changed after approval had "turned out to be pretty upsetting" (0:14:40). Patrick McCarty said the steel supplier is working on a detail that would recreate the 4-inch pilaster shadow line with metal panels (0:21:22). Members asked him to show the original and proposed designs side by side and to let the neighbors see the changes.

Bob said he and the town's lawyer agree the change is big enough that it has to go back to the Planning Board as a special permit modification (0:32:59). Because the footprint isn't changing, he said he would check whether he can let the builder pour the foundation in the meantime (0:37:18). The builder said that would let crews get ahead of winter. No vote was taken. The committee set an earlier meeting for September 3 so the builder can come back with revised drawings.

  • “I wouldn't be comfortable reversing what the board spent so much time on.” — Amy Poretsky (0:11:54)
  • “Lawyer and I both said, yes, given the situation” — Bob (0:32:59)
  • “in us guys in the building industry, we're already thinking about winter” — Patrick McCarty (0:35:44)

Celebree preschool plan draws questions on parking, rain gardens and roofline

Watch: 0:43:08–1:31:22

The project architect presented early plans for a one-story Celebree preschool of about 11,000 square feet at 300 West Main Street. The old bank building there would come down to make room for it. The design uses a flat roof hidden behind a mansard with false gables, a standing-seam metal roof in charcoal and a tower over the entrance. The Celebree franchisee and North Grafton resident said the school will serve infants through age five and that the area needs more daycare.

Parking got the most questions. "How many kids are roughly going to be in here?" asked a committee member. When he heard about 140, he pointed out that the plan shows 24 spaces on one side (1:04:31). He warned of car lines like the one at St. Bernadette's. The Celebree franchisee said drop-offs are spread through a 7 a.m. to 6:30 p.m. day and that daycares usually run 80 to 85 percent full (1:07:57). The property owner said the office part of the site has never "been close to being full" (1:09:55).

A committee member raised a safety worry about the rain garden near the drive: "you'd be surprised how fast they get away from you" (1:10:43). Fencing was suggested as a fix. Members also asked about snow sliding off the metal roof, where rooftop equipment and utilities will go, and what the playground surface will be made of. The architect said many of those details aren't decided yet.

There was a real split over the roofline. A committee member suggested adding gables to the plain rectangular back of the building, and a committee member asked for at least one more (1:22:02). The architect said the team could try it. The property owner pushed back: "I like it the way it is" (1:23:25). No vote was taken. The applicants will get a written list of items to address, along with a review from town planning staff, who had not yet seen the plans.

  • “Most day cares are never 100% full.” — the Celebree franchisee and North Grafton resident (1:07:04)
  • “I'm a little concerned with the rain garden children.” — a committee member (1:04:07)
  • “this is a preliminary presentation” — the project architect (1:11:51)

Municipal signs: design approved, stone wall debated

Watch: 1:49:10–2:25:00

The committee went back to the new town building signs to take a formal vote, because the town had asked for an official one (1:53:05). Scott Charpentier said each sign's setback depends on where the state highway right-of-way runs at that site. He put it at about 1 foot behind the Town Hall sign post, 10 feet at the police station and 12 feet at the highway garage (2:10:06).

Members disagreed over what to put at the base of the Town Hall sign. A committee member wanted to reuse field stone from an old wall: "I know, but the look is very important" (2:01:30). The public works representative said taking the wall apart is a day's work for a couple of laborers. He also said the stones would not match, because the outside faces have been weathered "for literally 40 years" (2:02:16). He said his crews maintain "safe roadways and parks and cemeteries" and don't build stone walls (2:00:16). He suggested a low wall of gray Versa-Lok block with plantings instead. A committee member said "I just don't want it to look industrial" (2:08:16). That question was left open.

Amy Poretsky said the signs must be finished by the end of the year (2:10:06). The committee first voted unanimously on the sign artwork and layout so the sign maker can start production. A second vote set the mounting height. Most signs will hang 27 inches above grade, measured to the sign's horizontal center line, and the library sign will sit lower at 24 inches. The senior center sign stays as it is. Final locations, including how much of the library's concrete gets removed, will come back on September 3.

Scott Charpentier said the town can pay for the signs once they are fabricated and stored, and will hold back 5 percent until the job is complete (2:22:32). Members also agreed to send the final design to the fire chief so the department's sign matches the others.

  • Motion: Approve the sign artwork and layout last sent to the sign maker so production can begin — Passed unanimously (2:13:28)
  • Motion: Set sign heights: 27 inches above grade to the horizontal center line for Town Hall, police and DPW; library sign lowered to 24 inches; senior center unchanged — Approved (vote count not stated) (2:17:13)
  • “We maintain safe roadways and parks and cemeteries so we're a little bit of a different priority list.” — Scott Charpentier (2:00:16)
  • “this has to be done by the end of the year” — Amy Poretsky (2:10:06)

Other business

112 West Main Street – Alliance sign

Watch: 1:32:01–1:38:38

A Sign Design Zone representative described the plan for the existing sign at the former Coleman House: new cedar panels with Alliance branding and a dimensional "112" address number. The sign's frame and posts stay and will be repainted. Members asked to add "West Main Street" in black lettering and plantings at the base, as part of the town's downtown revitalization push. The sign was approved as amended, with a revised drawing to be emailed to town staff.

  • Motion: Approve the Alliance sign as amended, adding West Main Street to the sign and landscaping at its base — Approved (vote count not stated) (1:38:28)

96 West Main Street – signs

Watch: 1:38:43–1:49:08

Matt is replacing tenant panels with matte aluminum composite, because the old PVC panels had warped. Members asked for more black space around the logos and a smaller phone number. Amy Poretsky said the committee wants to keep phone numbers and websites off signs in the future. The signs were treated as approved with those changes, though no formal vote was heard. Amy Poretsky said sign applications will go first on future agendas.

Minutes approved

Watch: 2:25:02–2:26:33

The committee approved the April 16 minutes as amended, the May 13 minutes, and the June 11 minutes amended to correct where the meeting was held. The next meeting is September 3.

  • Motion: Approve April 16, 2026 minutes as amended — Approved (vote count not stated) (2:25:02)
  • Motion: Approve May 13, 2026 minutes — Approved (vote count not stated) (2:25:02)
  • Motion: Approve June 11, 2026 minutes as amended — Approved (vote count not stated) (2:26:33)

Who spoke

  • Unidentified speaker (S1), a committee member — 31 min, 59 sec, 28% of speaking time, 314 turns
  • Patrick McCarty (likely), the builder for the project — 15 min, 36 sec, 14% of speaking time, 107 turns
  • Amy Poretsky, the chair — 14 min, 40 sec, 13% of speaking time, 187 turns
  • Unidentified speaker (S4), the project architect — 12 min, 29 sec, 11% of speaking time, 100 turns
  • Unidentified speaker (S5), a committee member — 12 min, 14 sec, 11% of speaking time, 133 turns
  • Bob (likely), the building inspector — 7 min, 55 sec, 7% of speaking time, 125 turns
  • Unidentified speaker (S7), the Celebree franchisee and North Grafton resident — 7 min, 27 sec, 7% of speaking time, 38 turns
  • Scott Charpentier, Public Works Director — 6 min, 37 sec, 6% of speaking time, 84 turns
  • Matt (likely), a D Signs representative — 1 min, 49 sec, 2% of speaking time, 25 turns
  • Unidentified speaker (S10), the property owner — 1 min, 46 sec, 2% of speaking time, 12 turns

Possible Open Meeting Law issues

This meeting hasn't been reviewed for Open Meeting Law issues.

See the Open Meeting Law page on Mass.gov for information on the Open Meeting Law.

Summary last updated Nov 14, 2026 at 6:09 PM.